Judge rules Brooke Rollins's Christmas and Easter emails to USDA staff likely violated the Establishment Clause; USDA weighs an appeal
A federal judge ruled on November 19, 2026, that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's Christmas and Easter emails to all USDA staff likely violated the Establishment Clause. USDA called the injunction an attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary and is weighing an appeal.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- Judge Trina L. Thompson granted a preliminary injunction on November 19, 2026, finding that Rollins's December 23, 2025, and April 5, 2026, messages to all USDA employees likely violated the Establishment Clause.National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss (opens in a new tab)
- The order requires Rollins to follow USDA Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019 when she sends messages with religious content, and it expresses no view on what she does in her personal capacity.National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss (opens in a new tab)
- Thompson dismissed the plaintiffs' two Administrative Procedure Act claims, ruling that the emails are not final agency action. The constitutional claim goes forward.National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss (opens in a new tab)Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emails (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- Whether the holiday emails coerce employees and favor one religion: the union and employees say they do; USDA says they follow a tradition of religious references in official speech and coerce no one.National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief (opens in a new tab)National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): defendants' opposition to the preliminary injunction motion and cross-motion to dismiss (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- Whether the injunction overreaches: USDA calls it an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary, while the order says the court does not regulate her religiosity.Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emails (opens in a new tab)National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss (opens in a new tab)See the claim
Not yet known
- Whether USDA will appeal the injunction to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
- Whether Rollins will send a department-wide Christmas message in 2026, and what it will say.
Overview
Rollins became agriculture secretary in February 2025 and has sent department-wide messages on holidays including the Fourth of July, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter. On November 20, 2025, USDA issued Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019 on religious expression at work, which says officials may discuss their faith with interested colleagues but cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates and must stop if a colleague asks. The union and seven employees sued on May 13, 2026, and moved for a preliminary injunction on July 22. Thompson heard the motions on October 27. A further case management conference is set for December 17, 2026.
People in this case
Brooke RollinsDirectly involved
Timeline
8 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 20, 2025 to November 20, 2026
November 2025
USDA issues a memorandum on religious expression at work
Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019 says USDA officials may discuss their faith with interested colleagues and invite coworkers to services, but cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates and must stop if a colleague asks.
December 2025
Rollins emails all USDA employees a Christmas video message
Incident
In the video, Rollins says the spirit of generosity flows from the first Christmas, when God gave the gift of his Son, "our Savior Jesus Christ".
April 2026
Rollins sends all USDA employees an Easter email
Incident
The email, addressed to "Team USDA", celebrates the resurrection of Jesus and compares employees to the first disciples. An illustration of the empty tomb at the top carries the words "Christ is Risen".
May 2026
A federal workers union and USDA employees sue Rollins over the messages
Source release
The National Federation of Federal Employees and seven employees file suit in federal court in San Francisco, claiming the holiday emails violate the Establishment Clause and the Administrative Procedure Act. Rollins answers on X the same day.
August 2026
USDA asks the court to deny an injunction and dismiss the case
Claim
Justice Department lawyers for the department and Rollins argue that the emails follow a tradition of religious references in official speech, coerce no one and favor no denomination.
October 2026
Judge Trina L. Thompson hears the injunction and dismissal motions
The hearing in San Francisco covered the plaintiffs' July 22 motion for a preliminary injunction and the department's cross-motion to dismiss.
November 2026
Thompson grants a preliminary injunction on the Establishment Clause claim
Incident
Thompson finds the Christmas and Easter messages likely amounted to coercive pressure, orders Rollins to follow her department's memorandum when she sends religious messages, and dismisses the two Administrative Procedure Act claims.
USDA says it is weighing an appeal
Reaction
A department spokesperson calls the order an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary and says USDA is evaluating all options, including a prompt appeal.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
National Federation of Federal Employees
Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's religious holiday emails to all USDA employees pressure employees to conform to her Christian beliefs and favor one religion, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
What is disputed
The union and USDA employees argue in their complaint that the messages amount to religious coercion and a denominational preference, because employees are expected to read the secretary's emails and Rollins has not marked other religions' holidays. USDA argues the emails fit a long tradition of religious references in official speech, do not ask employees to do anything and favor no denomination. At the preliminary stage, Judge Trina L. Thompson found that the December 23, 2025, Christmas message and the April 5, 2026, Easter email likely went too far and amounted to coercive pressure. The case has not reached a final judgment.
Sources (3)
- National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 1, filed May 13, 2026: introduction (paragraphs 1-6) and the description of the Christmas and Easter messages
- National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): defendants' opposition to the preliminary injunction motion and cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 38, filed August 21, 2026: introduction, pages 1-2 of the memorandum
- National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 59, filed November 19, 2026: pages 1-2 (summary of the order), page 4 (text of the Easter email), pages 14-17 (coercion analysis) and pages 20-21 (conclusion)
U.S. Department of Agriculture
The November 19, 2026, injunction is an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary.
What is disputed
A USDA spokesperson made the claim on November 20 and said the department is weighing an appeal. Thompson's order says the court does not purport to regulate the secretary's religiosity and expresses no view on what she does in her personal capacity. It requires her to follow her own department's memorandum on religious expression when she sends messages with religious content.
Sources (3)
- Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emailsArticle, November 20, 2026
- Judge blocks Brooke Rollins from sending Christian emails to USDA staff · Fox NewsFox News Digital article, November 21, 2026
- National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 59, filed November 19, 2026: pages 1-2 (summary of the order), page 4 (text of the Easter email), pages 14-17 (coercion analysis) and pages 20-21 (conclusion)
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
U.S. Department of AgricultureFederal executive department, in a statement from a spokesperson to Agweek"this is a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary; the Department is evaluating all options including a prompt appeal."
Stood by itResponding to: The November 19, 2026, injunction is an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary.
Full statement and sources
A USDA spokesperson told Agweek on November 20 that the injunction was an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary and that the department was weighing all options, including a prompt appeal. A spokesperson gave Fox News Digital a similar statement.
Before the statement
Thompson's November 19 order found that Rollins's December 2025 Christmas message and April 2026 Easter email likely went too far, and required her to follow her department's memorandum on religious expression when she sends messages with religious content.
After the statement
A case management conference in the lawsuit is set for December 17, 2026.
Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emailsArticle, November 20, 2026Judge blocks Brooke Rollins from sending Christian emails to USDA staff · Fox NewsFox News Digital article, November 21, 2026Trump's Agriculture Secretary Ordered To Stop Sending Christian Emails · HuffPostArticle, November 19, 2026, updated with USDA's responseWhy this label?
The department repeats its objection to the ruling, calling it an attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary, and says it may appeal, so we labeled it Stands by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
U.S. Department of AgricultureFederal executive department and defendant, in a court filing by its Justice Department lawyers"The emails also fail to exhibit the foremost hallmark of religious establishments that the First Amendment was designed to prevent: coercion of religious orthodoxy. They do not request, much less coerce, anyone to do anything. Nor do they establish a denominational preference. So they do not violate the Establishment Clause."
DeniedResponding to: Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's religious holiday emails to all USDA employees pressure employees to conform to her Christian beliefs and favor one religion, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Full statement and sources
In its filing opposing the injunction and asking the court to dismiss the case, the department argued that Rollins's holiday emails fit the nation's tradition of religious references in official speech, do not ask employees to do anything and do not violate the Establishment Clause.
Before the statement
The plaintiffs moved for a preliminary injunction on July 22, 2026. The department's filing opens by arguing that the Constitution does not mandate secularism in government affairs and that Rollins sent emails wishing employees well on holidays including the Fourth of July, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter and Memorial Day.
After the statement
The filing also argues that the plaintiffs lack standing because offense at religious messages is not a legal injury. On November 19, Thompson denied the motion to dismiss the constitutional claim and granted the injunction.
National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): defendants' opposition to the preliminary injunction motion and cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 38, filed August 21, 2026: introduction, pages 1-2 of the memorandumNational Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 59, filed November 19, 2026: pages 1-2 (summary of the order), page 4 (text of the Easter email), pages 14-17 (coercion analysis) and pages 20-21 (conclusion)Why this label?
USDA rejects the employees' claim that the emails coerce staff or favor one religion and says they are lawful, so we labeled it Denies.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Brooke RollinsU.S. secretary of agriculture, in a post on her official X account"It's just another opportunity to remind everyone: He is Risen."
Stood by itResponding to: Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's religious holiday emails to all USDA employees pressure employees to conform to her Christian beliefs and favor one religion, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Full statement and sources
Responding to the lawsuit over her religious holiday emails, Rollins posted on her official X account that it was another opportunity to repeat the Easter greeting "He is Risen".
Before the statement
The National Federation of Federal Employees and USDA employees sued Rollins and the department on May 13, 2026. Her April 5 Easter email to all USDA employees had begun "He is risen indeed!"
After the statement
When the suit was filed, a USDA spokesperson told Agweek the department does not comment on pending litigation, adding, "We will keep the plaintiffs in our prayers during this process."
Secretary Brooke Rollins on X: 'just another opportunity to remind everyone: He is Risen' · Brooke RollinsPost on X, May 13, 2026Trump's Agriculture Secretary Ordered To Stop Sending Christian Emails · HuffPostArticle, November 19, 2026, updated with USDA's responseJudge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emailsArticle, November 20, 2026National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss · United States District Court for the Northern District of CaliforniaDocument 59, filed November 19, 2026: pages 1-2 (summary of the order), page 4 (text of the Easter email), pages 14-17 (coercion analysis) and pages 20-21 (conclusion)Why this label?
Rollins answers the lawsuit by repeating the Easter greeting the employees objected to, so we labeled it Stands by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
2 responses. Newest first.
Randy ErwinPresident of the National Federation of Federal Employees, a plaintiff, in a statement released by the plaintiffs' lawyers "Federal employees shouldn't feel pressured to participate in religious expression or be made to feel that their faith, or lack thereof, affects their standing in the workplace. This ruling is an important victory for the First Amendment and for the core American principle that workplaces, especially those within the federal government, must respect the religious freedom of every employee."
CondemnedResponding to: Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's religious holiday emails to all USDA employees pressure employees to conform to her Christian beliefs and favor one religion, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Full statement and sources
Erwin, whose union is a plaintiff, welcomed the injunction and said federal employees should not be made to feel that their faith affects their standing at work.
Before the statement
Erwin opened the statement by saying that federal employees "are public servants, not an audience for their bosses' personal religious beliefs". The union represents about 110,000 federal workers, including thousands at USDA.
After the statement
He said the union would keep defending its members' constitutional rights and their ability to serve the public free from religious coercion.
Federal court blocks USDA secretary's proselytizing federal workers · Americans United for Separation of Church and StatePress release, November 19, 2026Judge halts Brooke Rollins' Christian messages to USDA staffArticle, November 20, 2026Judge blocks Brooke Rollins from sending Christian emails to USDA staff · Fox NewsFox News Digital article, November 21, 2026Why this label?
Erwin says federal workers should not be pressured to take part in religious expression at work and calls the ruling against Rollins's emails a victory for the First Amendment, so we labeled it Condemns.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Americans United for Separation of Church and StateReligious freedom advocacy group representing the plaintiffs, in a statement by its president and CEO, Rachel Laser "Today's decision should send a message to the Trump administration that it cannot misuse taxpayer resources to preach, hold government-sponsored prayer services during work time, and broadcast Christian Nationalism over official communication channels. Not on our watch."
CondemnedResponding to: Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's religious holiday emails to all USDA employees pressure employees to conform to her Christian beliefs and favor one religion, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Full statement and sources
Rachel Laser, president and CEO of Americans United, which represents the plaintiffs, said the group applauds the decision to stop Rollins from abusing the power of her office to impose her beliefs, and that the decision should tell the Trump administration it cannot misuse taxpayer resources to preach, hold prayer services during work time or broadcast Christian Nationalism over official channels.
Before the statement
Laser began by saying Americans United applauded the decision "to stop Secretary Rollins from continuing to abuse the power of her public office to impose her beliefs on others".
After the statement
Americans United, Democracy Forward and Bryan Schwartz Law represent the union and six USDA employees in the lawsuit.
Federal court blocks USDA secretary's proselytizing federal workers · Americans United for Separation of Church and StatePress release, November 19, 2026Why this label?
Laser says the administration cannot misuse taxpayer resources to preach or broadcast Christian Nationalism over official channels, and welcomes the order against Rollins's emails, so we labeled it Condemns.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(9)
Original text
National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): order granting preliminary injunction and denying cross-motion to dismiss
Relevant passage: Document 59, filed November 19, 2026: pages 1-2 (summary of the order), page 4 (text of the Easter email), pages 14-17 (coercion analysis) and pages 20-21 (conclusion)
About this source
Judge Trina L. Thompson's order granting the union and USDA employees a preliminary injunction on their Establishment Clause claim against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins. The order dismisses the plaintiffs' two Administrative Procedure Act claims, finds the December 23, 2025, Christmas message and the April 5, 2026, Easter email likely went too far, and orders Rollins to follow her department's own memorandum on religious expression when she sends messages with religious content.
- Author
- Trina L. Thompson
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trump's Agriculture Secretary Ordered To Stop Sending Christian Emails
Relevant passage: Article, November 19, 2026, updated with USDA's response
About this source
HuffPost's report on the injunction. It quotes the December 2025 Christmas note and April Easter email, the complaint, the order, plaintiff Ashley Miller and a USDA spokesperson's emailed statement.
- Author
- Dave Jamieson
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Judge halts Brooke Rollins' Christian messages to USDA staff
Relevant passage: Article, November 20, 2026
About this source
Deseret News report on the injunction that sets the complaint's arguments beside USDA's defense in court, including the department's argument that the Constitution does not require secularism in government affairs.
- Author
- Emily Walker, Deseret News
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Judge blocks Brooke Rollins from sending Christian emails to USDA staff
Relevant passage: Fox News Digital article, November 21, 2026
About this source
Fox News Digital's report on the injunction. It quotes the order on the messages' use of first-person plural pronouns, NFFE president Randy Erwin, and a USDA spokesperson's statement to Fox News Digital calling the ruling an attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary.
- Author
- Elaine Mallon
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emails
Relevant passage: Article, November 20, 2026
About this source
Agweek's report on the injunction. It summarizes the coercion finding and the dismissal of the APA claims, and carries a USDA spokesperson's statement to Agweek on November 20 that the department is weighing an appeal, along with the department's May reply to the lawsuit and Rollins's post on X.
- Author
- Noah Fish, Agweek
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Federal court blocks USDA secretary's proselytizing federal workers
Relevant passage: Press release, November 19, 2026
About this source
Americans United's release on the injunction, issued for the plaintiffs' legal team. It quotes the order and carries statements from plaintiff Ashley Miller, NFFE president Randy Erwin, Americans United president Rachel Laser, Democracy Forward senior counsel Sarah Goetz and attorney Bryan Schwartz.
- Author
- Americans United for Separation of Church and State
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Secretary Brooke Rollins on X: 'just another opportunity to remind everyone: He is Risen'
About this source
Rollins's post on her official X account on the day the lawsuit was filed. It links a USA Today report on the complaint.
- Author
- Brooke Rollins
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): defendants' opposition to the preliminary injunction motion and cross-motion to dismiss
Relevant passage: Document 38, filed August 21, 2026: introduction, pages 1-2 of the memorandum
About this source
The Justice Department's filing for USDA and Secretary Brooke Rollins. It argues that the holiday emails fit a long tradition of religious references in official speech, that they do not coerce employees or favor one denomination, and that the plaintiffs lack standing.
- Author
- Brett A. Shumate; Noah T. Katzen; Elisabeth J. Neylan
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406 (N.D. Cal.): complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief
Relevant passage: Document 1, filed May 13, 2026: introduction (paragraphs 1-6) and the description of the Christmas and Easter messages
About this source
The complaint filed by the National Federation of Federal Employees and seven USDA employees against the department and Secretary Brooke Rollins in her official capacity. It quotes Rollins's holiday messages to all USDA employees and argues they amount to religious coercion and a denominational preference barred by the Establishment Clause.
- Author
- Americans United for Separation of Church and State; Democracy Forward Foundation; Bryan Schwartz Law
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Judge rules Brooke Rollins's Christmas and Easter emails to USDA staff likely violated the Establishment Clause; USDA weighs an appeal
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/brooke-rollins-usda-religious-emails-injunction
The Dispute Index. "Judge rules Brooke Rollins's Christmas and Easter emails to USDA staff likely violated the Establishment Clause; USDA weighs an appeal". First published: 2026-11-22. Last updated: 2026-11-22. https://disputeindex.com/cases/brooke-rollins-usda-religious-emails-injunction