All topics

Russia

Public disputes concerning Russia, including its government, institutions, officials and citizens, and disputes over Russia's relations with other states.

Published coverage on this page: 4+ cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.

Topic updates

Follow this topic

Get free email updates about Russia. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.

Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.

We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.

Related cases

More cases

Statements

Filter by response label

Labels describe a response to the linked claim or the action explained in the statement summary. Choose one or more.

178 matching statements

Portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Role at the time: President of Ukraine, in a post on his X account

Condemned

Statement summary

Zelenskyy says many Russian drone strikes on substations are getting through because Starshield speed limits remain along the front line and in occupied territory. He says protecting lives and Ukraine's energy grid before winter depends on lifting the limits and urges the American side and SpaceX to help Ukraine.

Quotation excerpt

“And many of these strikes are getting through because restrictions on the operating speed of Starshield terminals along the front line and in the temporarily occupied territories are still there. ... We are counting on these restrictions…”
Read full quotation
“And many of these strikes are getting through because restrictions on the operating speed of Starshield terminals along the front line and in the temporarily occupied territories are still there. ... We are counting on these restrictions being lifted. ... It is important to be on the right side of history. It is essential to help Ukraine.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Volodymyr Zelenskyy on X: Starshield restrictions let Russian strikes on substations throughSecond paragraph of the English-language post

What this label refers to

Zelenskyy blames the remaining Starshield limits for Russian strikes getting through and presses Washington and SpaceX to lift them, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Jimmy Panetta

Jimmy Panetta

Role at the time: U.S. representative from California, in a post on X

Condemned

Statement summary

Sharing a report on renewed Starshield disruptions in Ukraine, Panetta says he has repeatedly called on the Pentagon and the White House to answer for what he calls reckless disruptions and to restore full service, and says Ukraine needs the tools to defend its democracy.

“I have consistently called on the Pentagon and the White House to answer for these reckless disruptions and ensure service is fully restored. We must stand with Ukraine to ensure it has the tools to defend its democracy.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Jimmy Panetta on X: Starshield disruptions are hindering Ukraine's defenseFull post

What this label refers to

Panetta calls the disruptions reckless and demands that the Pentagon and the White House answer for them and restore service, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Role at the time: President of Ukraine, in a post on his X account

Condemned

Statement summary

Zelenskyy says the Starshield limit of 161 km/h for Ukrainian forces remains along the whole front line and in occupied territory, which he says rules out interceptors against jet-powered Shahed drones. He says Kyiv still has no clear explanation and that he told the Foreign Ministry and the Defense Minister to press the State Department, the Pentagon and SpaceX for one.

Quotation excerpt

“Unfortunately, the speed limit of 161 kilometers per hour (100 miles per hour) for our forces remains in place along the entire front line and in Ukraine's temporarily occupied territories. This makes it impossible, in particular, to use…”
Read full quotation
“Unfortunately, the speed limit of 161 kilometers per hour (100 miles per hour) for our forces remains in place along the entire front line and in Ukraine's temporarily occupied territories. This makes it impossible, in particular, to use interceptors against jet-powered "shaheds." We still have no clear explanations. I instructed Ukraine's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Minister of Defense to step up contacts with the U.S. Department of State, the Pentagon, and SpaceX to obtain clarification and resolve the situation.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Volodymyr Zelenskyy (@ZelenskyyUa) on X, November 13, 2026: 'We still have no clear explanations' · Volodymyr ZelenskyySecond paragraph of the post of November 13, 2026, 12:18 UTC

What this label refers to

Zelenskyy says the speed limit still keeps Ukrainian interceptors from stopping jet-powered Shaheds, says Kyiv has no clear explanation for it and orders contacts with Washington and SpaceX to fix it, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Adam Smith

Adam Smith

Role at the time: U.S. representative from Washington and ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee, in a joint statement with Rep. Gregory W. Meeks

Condemned

Statement summary

Smith and Meeks say the earlier Starshield limits were intentional and contributed to civilian casualties and the deaths of children in Ukraine. They say any restrictions weaken Ukraine's defense of its citizens and strengthen Putin's position in negotiations.

Quotation excerpt

“The previous intentional limitations placed on Ukraine's use of Starshield contributed to Ukrainian civilian casualties and the deaths of Ukrainian children. Any restrictions hamper Ukraine's ability to defend its citizens, strengthen…”
Read full quotation
“The previous intentional limitations placed on Ukraine's use of Starshield contributed to Ukrainian civilian casualties and the deaths of Ukrainian children. Any restrictions hamper Ukraine's ability to defend its citizens, strengthen Putin's hand at the negotiating table, and further Russia's efforts to consolidate control over sovereign Ukrainian territory.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Ranking Members Meeks, Smith Issue Statement on Reports of New Disruptions to Starshield in UkraineFull joint statement

What this label refers to

Smith says the earlier limits were intentional and contributed to civilian deaths, and that any new restrictions weaken Ukraine and help Putin, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Gregory W. Meeks

Gregory W. Meeks

Role at the time: U.S. representative from New York and ranking member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, in a joint statement with Rep. Adam Smith

Condemned

Statement summary

Meeks and Smith call the reported new Starshield limits over occupied territory and the front line unacceptable if accurate. They say Trump, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner have pressed Ukraine to give up territory instead of pressuring Russia to end the war.

Quotation excerpt

“The reports of renewed limitations on Ukraine's use of Starshield in Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory ... if accurate, are unacceptable. For two years, Trump, Witkoff, and Kushner have tried to strong-arm Ukraine into giving up…”
Read full quotation
“The reports of renewed limitations on Ukraine's use of Starshield in Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory ... if accurate, are unacceptable. For two years, Trump, Witkoff, and Kushner have tried to strong-arm Ukraine into giving up territory and surrendering, instead of pressuring Russia to end its war of aggression.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Ranking Members Meeks, Smith Issue Statement on Reports of New Disruptions to Starshield in UkraineFull joint statement

What this label refers to

Meeks calls the reported renewed limits on Ukraine's Starshield use unacceptable and ties them to what he describes as pressure from Trump, Witkoff and Kushner on Ukraine to give up territory, so we labeled it Condemned.

Logo of SpaceX

SpaceX

Role at the time: Operator of the Starshield satellite system, in a statement to Axios

Denied

Statement summary

Responding to Axios after Zelenskyy said Starshield speeds were again limited along the front line and in occupied areas, SpaceX says the report is false and that there has been no change.

“This is false. There has been no change”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Zelensky says Musk-owned satellite system throttled again, Space X denies it · AxiosSpaceX's response under The other side; a Ukrainian official and Denys Sienik under Zoom in

What this label refers to

SpaceX rejects Zelenskyy's account of renewed restrictions and says there has been no change, so we labeled it Denied.

Portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Role at the time: President of Ukraine, in a post on his X account quoting his address to the European Political Community summit

Condemned

Statement summary

In a post quoting his address to the European Political Community summit, Zelenskyy says Starshield speeds are again limited to 161 km/h over occupied parts of Ukraine, which he says keeps interceptor drones from catching Russian jet-powered Shahed drones in time. He says more Russian strikes get through, that Ukraine is seeking details from the American side but knows very little so far, and that decisions in America treating Ukrainian territory as not Ukrainian would show where things are going.

Quotation excerpt

“This means more Russian strikes get through, and more of our people are killed by Russia. We are trying to get the details from the American side, but so far, we know very little. If someone in America is making decisions that basically…”
Read full quotation
“This means more Russian strikes get through, and more of our people are killed by Russia. We are trying to get the details from the American side, but so far, we know very little. If someone in America is making decisions that basically treat Ukrainian territory as if it is not Ukrainian, then this tells us where things are going.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Volodymyr Zelenskyy (@ZelenskyyUa) on X, November 12, 2026: 'The speed limit is back at 161 kilometers per hour' · Volodymyr ZelenskyyComplete post of November 12, 2026, 14:19 UTC, marked 3/3, with video of the address

What this label refers to

Zelenskyy says the renewed limits mean more Russian strikes get through and more Ukrainians are killed, and he warns against decisions in America that treat occupied Ukrainian land as not Ukrainian, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Chris Wright

Chris Wright

Role at the time: U.S. secretary of energy, speaking to reporters at an event in New Orleans, as quoted by Reuters

Defended or excused

Statement summary

With the first tanker of Russian diesel for the United States idling off the East Coast, Wright says he is confident the cargo will help supply global markets even if it does not land at a U.S. port, according to Reuters.

“We just want that diesel going into the world markets”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Reuters, via Baird Maritime: US firms look less likely to import idled tanker's Russian diesel · ReutersFull article; Wright's remark in the sixth paragraph

What this label refers to

Wright says the cargo will still do its job by supplying world markets even if no U.S. buyer takes it, which defends the decision to ease the sanctions, so we labeled it defends or excuses.

Portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Role at the time: President of Ukraine, posting an excerpt of his DR interview on his official X account

Condemned

Response to this claim

A deal to end the war in Ukraine is close, and Ukraine will "end up with a little bit different shape" once it is done.

Quotation excerpt

“Ceding Ukrainian land for peace is just abstract words. It’s not only about reality, even more about philosophy. Putin was talking about Donbas, but then he decided to occupy Kyiv, our capital. ... Nobody trusts Putin to stop if we leave…”
Read full quotation
“Ceding Ukrainian land for peace is just abstract words. It’s not only about reality, even more about philosophy. Putin was talking about Donbas, but then he decided to occupy Kyiv, our capital. ... Nobody trusts Putin to stop if we leave Donbas. He will pause. Then he will come back in one year, two years, or five years.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Zelenskyy's X post quoting his DR interview on ceding land for peace · Volodymyr ZelenskyyX post of Nov. 10, 2026, 10:51 UTC, full text (second of three posts from the DR interview)
Why we used this label

Zelenskyy rejects trading Ukrainian land for peace, the outcome Trump's remark was read as signaling, and says Putin would only pause. Asked about the remark itself in the same interview, he said he was not ready for that kind of surprise.

Portrait of Andrii Sybiha

Andrii Sybiha

Role at the time: Minister of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine, in a post on X

Condemned

Statement summary

After the Security Council meeting, Ukraine's foreign minister Andrii Sybiha writes that Russian guided bombs killed at least 55 people waiting for aid in Komyshuvakha, that Ukraine's military intelligence has identified the pilots who dropped them and the officer who planned the strike, and that Ukraine will pursue every perpetrator.

Quotation excerpt

“In Komyshuvakha, Russian guided aerial bombs killed at least 55 people gathered to receive humanitarian aid. At least 70 lives taken in these two atrocities alone. Ukraine's military intelligence has already identified the Russian pilots…”
Read full quotation
“In Komyshuvakha, Russian guided aerial bombs killed at least 55 people gathered to receive humanitarian aid. At least 70 lives taken in these two atrocities alone. Ukraine's military intelligence has already identified the Russian pilots who dropped the bombs on Komyshuvakha, as well as the officer who planned the strike. We know their names. We will pursue every perpetrator, from those who released the bombs to those who issued the orders.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Andrii Sybiha (@andrii_sybiha) on X, November 9, 2026: 'The reason the Security Council met yesterday is written in blood in Dnipro and Komyshuvakha'Full post

What this label refers to

Sybiha calls the Komyshuvakha bombing an atrocity, says Ukraine knows the names of the Russian pilots and the officer behind it, and vows to pursue them for war crimes, so we labeled it Condemned.

Logo of Permanent Mission of the Russian Federation to the United Nations

Permanent Mission of the Russian Federation to the United Nations

Role at the time: Russia's diplomatic mission to the UN, in an emailed reply to Dispute Index from its head of media and communications, Evgeny Uspenskiy

Explicitly stayed out

Statement summary

Asked by Dispute Index whether Russia acknowledges striking the Komyshuvakha school and a shelter on November 2, Russia's Permanent Mission to the UN did not answer and referred questions about the incident and related military assessments to the Russian foreign and defence ministries. It pointed to its statement at the November 9 Security Council meeting on Ukraine.

“For comments on the specific circumstances of the reported incident and the related military assessments, we recommend that you contact the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Defence.”
Read the full email
Dear Graham, Thank you for your request. For comments on the specific circumstances of the reported incident and the related military assessments, we recommend that you contact the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Defence. For our part, we would like to note that, as a permanent member of the UN Security Council, the Russian Federation participates in all Council meetings. We also invite you to watch our statement on the matter: https://webtv.un.org/en/asset/k1g/k1grjs21ql Ourstatement will be publishedin English a bit later today on our website: https://russiaun.ru/en Best regards, Evgeny Uspenskiy Head of Media and Comunications Permanent Mission of the Russian Federation to the United Nations
Emailed reply from Russia's Permanent Mission to the UN to Dispute Index on the Komyshuvakha strike · Permanent Mission of the Russian Federation to the United NationsEmail from the mission's press office to Graham Weller of Dispute Index, November 9, 2026

What this label refers to

The reference point is the November 2 strike on the Komyshuvakha school used for aid and the shelter beside it. The mission did not say whether Russia struck the school or what target was there, and referred those questions to the foreign and defence ministries, so we labeled it Explicitly stayed out. The closest competing label is Denied, which fits the Defence Ministry's November 3 claim that it hit Ukrainian units near the village; this reply makes no claim about the strike itself.

Portrait of David E. Sanger

David E. Sanger

Role at the time: CNN political and national security analyst, on CNN News Central

Condemned

Statement summary

On CNN, Sanger says Trump's remark about disrespect to Russia fits a pattern of excusing or diminishing what Russia has done, and notes that Trump did not say Russia invaded Ukraine.

Quotation excerpt

“the President has gone out of his way to excuse or diminish what Russia has done. You notice there that he didn't jump in and say, yes, Russia invaded Ukraine and violated their sovereignty. And there's something of an imbalance between…”
Read full quotation
“the President has gone out of his way to excuse or diminish what Russia has done. You notice there that he didn't jump in and say, yes, Russia invaded Ukraine and violated their sovereignty. And there's something of an imbalance between somebody invading your country and you being rude to them when you meet them for the first time after they've invaded your country, right?”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)CNN News Central transcript, November 9, 2026: David Sanger on Trump's remark about Russia · CNNCNN News Central, 9:30 a.m. ET half hour; the Ukraine clip and Sanger answer at about 9:35 a.m. ET

What this label refers to

Sanger says Trump has gone out of his way to excuse Russia and faults him for weighing Ukrainian rudeness against an invasion, which criticizes the remark.

Portrait of James Stavridis

James Stavridis

Role at the time: CNN senior military analyst and retired admiral, former NATO supreme allied commander, interviewed on CNN News Central

Condemned

Response to this claim

A deal to end the war in Ukraine is close, and Ukraine will "end up with a little bit different shape" once it is done.

Quotation excerpt

“Well, it sounds ominous. What it probably portends is the 20 percent, roughly, of Ukraine that Putin is currently in control of, the eastern slice that connects Crimea up to the Rodina, the motherland, as the Russians say, about 20 percent.…”
Read full quotation
“Well, it sounds ominous. What it probably portends is the 20 percent, roughly, of Ukraine that Putin is currently in control of, the eastern slice that connects Crimea up to the Rodina, the motherland, as the Russians say, about 20 percent. It's kind of a trade land for peace deal, if you will. Certainly, Zelenskyy will hate that deal. I hate that deal. We all should hate that deal.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)CNN News Central transcript, November 9, 2026: James Stavridis on Trump's Ukraine remarks · CNNCNN News Central, 7:30 a.m. ET half hour; the Ukraine clip and Stavridis interview at about 7:35 a.m. ET
Why we used this label

Stavridis reads the remark as pointing to a land-for-peace deal and says he hates that deal and that everyone should. He expects talks to end there, but he criticizes the outcome rather than defending it.

Portrait of Dan Negrea

Dan Negrea

Role at the time: U.S. representative to the UN Economic and Social Council, delivering U.S. remarks at a Security Council briefing

Condemned

Statement summary

Speaking for the United States at the November 9 Security Council meeting, Ambassador Dan Negrea extends condolences to families who lost relatives in the strikes on Komyshuvakha and the Kharkiv hospital, says more must be done to protect civilians and calls for strikes on populated areas to end.

Quotation excerpt

“We extend our condolences to the many families who lost loved ones in the recent strikes on the village of Komyshuvakha, the humanitarian distribution site in Zaporizhzhia, and the Kharkiv hospital. Civilians caught in the crossfire of this…”
Read full quotation
“We extend our condolences to the many families who lost loved ones in the recent strikes on the village of Komyshuvakha, the humanitarian distribution site in Zaporizhzhia, and the Kharkiv hospital. Civilians caught in the crossfire of this war continue to pay the ultimate price ... Strikes on populated areas must end”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Remarks at a UN Security Council Briefing on the Situation in UkraineFull remarks as delivered by Ambassador Dan Negrea

What this label refers to

Negrea mourns the people killed at Komyshuvakha and says strikes on populated areas must end, addressing both Russia and Ukraine without naming who carried out the strike, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Andriy Melnyk

Andriy Melnyk

Role at the time: Ukraine's permanent representative to the United Nations, speaking at a Security Council meeting

Condemned

Statement summary

At the November 9 Security Council meeting, Ukraine's UN ambassador Andriy Melnyk says people had gathered at the Komyshuvakha school for humanitarian aid when Russian aircraft deliberately bombed it, and that a second strike hit the shelter where survivors and first responders had taken cover.

“On November 2, people gathered at the local school to receive humanitarian aid. Russian aircraft deliberately bombed this building.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Komyshuvakha, Mariupol Drama Theatre to serve as evidence to hold Russian war criminals accountable - Ukraine's UN envoyOpening paragraphs quoting Melnyk's Security Council remarks

What this label refers to

Melnyk says Russian aircraft bombed the school on purpose while people were collecting aid, then struck the shelter where survivors hid, and calls it one of Russia's gravest war crimes, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Guy Benson

Guy Benson

Role at the time: Host of The Guy Benson Show on Fox News Radio, interviewing Michael McFaul

Condemned

Statement summary

On his Fox News Radio show, Benson says he does not understand why Trump would object to Ukrainians disrespecting the Russians who invaded them, and that disrespect is the least they should feel.

Quotation excerpt

“I don’t understand why anyone, let alone the President of the United States, and I think some of his policies on Russia have been very good, not always, but why would he object to perceived disrespect by the Ukrainians for their invaders,…”
Read full quotation
“I don’t understand why anyone, let alone the President of the United States, and I think some of his policies on Russia have been very good, not always, but why would he object to perceived disrespect by the Ukrainians for their invaders, tormentors, the butchers of Moscow? I feel like disrespect is kind of the very least they should harbor. For the Russians.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)"Imagine Saying That After We Were Attacked On 9/11": Michael McFaul reacts to President Trump's 60 Minutes interview · Fox NewsFull transcript; the exchange on Trump's remark about disrespect to Russia opens the interview

What this label refers to

Benson objects to Trump's complaint that disrespect was shown to Russia, saying it is the least Ukrainians should feel toward their invaders. He praises some of Trump's Russia policies but criticizes this remark.

Portrait of Michael McFaul

Michael McFaul

Role at the time: Former U.S. ambassador to Russia and Hoover Institution senior fellow, interviewed on The Guy Benson Show on Fox News Radio

Condemned

Statement summary

On Fox News Radio, McFaul says Trump's complaint that Ukraine showed disrespect to Russia is like asking Americans to respect Al-Qaeda after the September 11 attacks, and that showing Putin respect makes no sense.

Quotation excerpt

“imagine saying that after we were attacked on September 11th, we need to show more respect to Al-Qaeda. This is just absolutely insane. ... You might have to negotiate with him, and President Zelensky said he’s willing to talk to Putin, but…”
Read full quotation
“imagine saying that after we were attacked on September 11th, we need to show more respect to Al-Qaeda. This is just absolutely insane. ... You might have to negotiate with him, and President Zelensky said he’s willing to talk to Putin, but to show respect for that individual just makes no sense. And I don’t understand why the president thinks that that resonates with anybody except for Vladimir Putin.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)"Imagine Saying That After We Were Attacked On 9/11": Michael McFaul reacts to President Trump's 60 Minutes interview · Fox NewsFull transcript; the exchange on Trump's remark about disrespect to Russia opens the interview

What this label refers to

McFaul calls the remark about disrespect to Russia absolutely insane and says it resonates with no one except Putin, which criticizes the remark.

Portrait of Dmitry Peskov

Dmitry Peskov

Role at the time: Kremlin spokesman, at a news briefing in Moscow

Defended or excused

Response to this claim

A deal to end the war in Ukraine is close, and Ukraine will "end up with a little bit different shape" once it is done.

“As for the shape of Ukraine, in terms of geography it is already a different country. The realities on the ground are obvious, and hardly anyone can deny them”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Ukraine 'already a different country' geographically, Kremlin saysFull article
Why we used this label

Peskov agrees with the remark, saying Ukraine has already changed shape in terms of geography and that no one can deny the realities on the ground. He backs the premise that Ukraine's borders have changed.

Portrait of Donald Trump

Donald Trump

Role at the time: President of the United States, in an interview with Ross Douthat for CBS's 60 Minutes

Denied

Statement summary

Asked by Ross Douthat on 60 Minutes who is in charge of the Starlink system in Ukraine's war zone, Trump or Musk, Trump says the slowdown was not his doing and that he cannot say who turned the service down, though Musk ultimately turned it back up. He adds that it has not been proven to him that the service was turned down.

“It wasn't me ... I can't tell you who turned it down ... It hasn't been proven to me that it was turned down ... But I know this, that when I heard about it, it went back up.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Read the full transcript of Ross Douthat's interview with President Trump · CBS NewsTranscript, exchange on Starlink, from "Last Ukraine question on the aid and support we give them"

What this label refers to

Trump says he did not cause the slowdown, says he cannot say who did and questions whether the service was turned down at all, so we labeled it Denied.

Logo of Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Latvia

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Latvia

Role at the time: Foreign ministry of Latvia, which holds the UN Security Council presidency in November 2026, in a press release

Condemned

Response to this claim

Russian forces dropped aerial bombs on a school in Komyshuvakha where residents were receiving humanitarian aid, then struck a shelter where people had taken cover, and could not have been unaware that residents received aid there every week.

Quotation excerpt

“At Ukraine's request, and with the support of Denmark, France, Greece and the United Kingdom, Latvia called for the emergency meeting in response to Russia's intensified attacks on Ukrainian civilians and critical civilian infrastructure,…”
Read full quotation
“At Ukraine's request, and with the support of Denmark, France, Greece and the United Kingdom, Latvia called for the emergency meeting in response to Russia's intensified attacks on Ukrainian civilians and critical civilian infrastructure, including the strikes on 2 November in Komyshuvakha, in the Zaporizhzhia region, where more than 50 people were killed in attacks on a humanitarian aid distribution point and a civilian shelter, followed by further strikes that also claimed the lives of rescue workers who had arrived at the scene.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Foreign Minister Baiba Braže will chair emergency UN Security Council meeting on Ukraine · Ministry of Foreign Affairs of LatviaSecond and third paragraphs of the press release, published November 8, 2026
Why we used this label

The reference point is the November 2 strike on the Komyshuvakha school used for aid and the shelter beside it. The ministry attributes the strikes to Russia, describes them as attacks on civilians and calls an emergency Security Council meeting in response, which condemns the strike.

Logo of Delegation of the European Union to the International Organisations in Vienna

Delegation of the European Union to the International Organisations in Vienna

Role at the time: EU delegation to the international organisations in Vienna, delivering the European Union's statement at the OSCE Permanent Council

Condemned

Statement summary

In its statement to the OSCE Permanent Council in Vienna on November 5, the European Union says Russia launched one of its most brutal attacks against civilians on November 2, when aerial bombs struck a school in Komyshuvakha used for humanitarian purposes and shelter. The statement put the toll at that time at least 40 dead, including two rescuers and four police officers.

Quotation excerpt

“On Monday of this week (2 November), Russia launched one of its most brutal and repugnant attacks against civilians in Ukraine. A school used for humanitarian purposes and shelter in Komyshuvakha in the Zaporizhzhia region was struck by…”
Read full quotation
“On Monday of this week (2 November), Russia launched one of its most brutal and repugnant attacks against civilians in Ukraine. A school used for humanitarian purposes and shelter in Komyshuvakha in the Zaporizhzhia region was struck by aerial bombs.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)EU Statement on the Russian Federation's ongoing aggression against Ukraine (OSCE Permanent Council No. 1584)Paragraphs 1 and 2

What this label refers to

The EU attributes the Komyshuvakha strike to Russia, calls it one of Russia's most brutal and repugnant attacks on civilians and says it shows contempt for humanitarian efforts and international law, so we labeled it Condemned.

Logo of Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel

Role at the time: Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, in a post on its official X account

Condemned

Statement summary

In a post on X, Israel's Foreign Ministry attributes the Komyshuvakha attack to Russia, says it is deeply saddened, condemns the attack and offers condolences to the families of those killed.

Quotation excerpt

“Deeply saddened by the horrific news from Komyshuvakha, Ukraine, where 40 people were killed in a Russian attack. Among the civilian sites struck was a school serving as a humanitarian aid distribution centre. Many people are still…”
Read full quotation
“Deeply saddened by the horrific news from Komyshuvakha, Ukraine, where 40 people were killed in a Russian attack. Among the civilian sites struck was a school serving as a humanitarian aid distribution centre. Many people are still missing. We condemn this attack and extend our heartfelt condolences to the families of those killed. We wish the wounded a swift and full recovery.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Israel Foreign Ministry (@IsraelMFA) on X, November 4, 2026: 'Deeply saddened by the horrific news from Komyshuvakha, Ukraine' · Ministry of Foreign Affairs of IsraelPost of November 4, 2026, 15:31 UTC

What this label refers to

The ministry attributes the attack to Russia, notes that a school used to hand out aid was among the sites hit and says it condemns the attack, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Role at the time: President of Ukraine, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

Russian forces dropped aerial bombs on a school in Komyshuvakha where residents were receiving humanitarian aid, then struck a shelter where people had taken cover, and could not have been unaware that residents received aid there every week.

Quotation excerpt

“Unfortunately, there has been very little reaction from the world to this insane attack. But it, like thousands upon thousands of other war crimes Russia has committed against Ukraine and Ukrainians, demands a strong response. Evil always…”
Read full quotation
“Unfortunately, there has been very little reaction from the world to this insane attack. But it, like thousands upon thousands of other war crimes Russia has committed against Ukraine and Ukrainians, demands a strong response. Evil always goes further if it is left unanswered.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Zelenskyy's X post on the third day of the Komyshuvakha search · Volodymyr ZelenskyyFull post, November 4, 2026
Why we used this label

The reference point is the November 2 strike on the Komyshuvakha school used for aid and the shelter beside it. Zelenskyy calls it an insane attack, counts it among Russia's war crimes against Ukraine and says it demands a strong response, which condemns the strike.

Logo of UK Delegation to the OSCE

UK Delegation to the OSCE

Role at the time: UK Senior Military Advisor Colonel Joby Rimmer, delivering the UK statement to the OSCE Forum for Security Co-operation in Vienna

Condemned

Statement summary

At the OSCE Forum for Security Co-operation in Vienna, the UK delegation's Senior Military Advisor, Colonel Joby Rimmer, condemns the November 2 Komyshuvakha strike as a Russian double-tap attack on civilians collecting aid. The rest of the statement disputes the evidence Russia has presented to the forum for its own claims about attacks.

Quotation excerpt

“We also unequivocally condemn Russia's double-tap strike on 2 November against civilians gathering for humanitarian aid in Komyshuvakha, which killed at least 33 people, including police officers and rescue workers. Once again, it is…”
Read full quotation
“We also unequivocally condemn Russia's double-tap strike on 2 November against civilians gathering for humanitarian aid in Komyshuvakha, which killed at least 33 people, including police officers and rescue workers. Once again, it is Ukrainian civilians who are paying the price for Russia's strike campaign.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Russia must show the evidence behind its claims: UK statement to the OSCE · UK Delegation to the OSCEFull statement, delivered November 4, 2026

What this label refers to

The UK attributes the Komyshuvakha strike to Russia, describes it as a double-tap strike on civilians gathering for aid and says it unequivocally condemns it, so we labeled it Condemned.

Older statements

People in this topic

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Volodymyr Zelenskyy is the president of Ukraine, in office since May 20, 2019. Before entering politics he was an actor, comedian and television producer, and a co-founder of the production company Kvartal 95.

7 cases and 12 statements

Jimmy Panetta

United States Representative and Democratic candidate for U.S. House in California's 19th district.

1 case and 1 statement

Adam Smith

United States Representative and Democratic candidate for U.S. House in Washington's 9th district.

1 case and 1 statement

Gregory W. Meeks

United States Representative and Democratic candidate for U.S. House in New York's 5th district.

3 cases and 3 statements

Chris Wright

Chris Wright is the 17th U.S. Secretary of Energy, confirmed by the Senate on February 3, 2025. He founded the oilfield technology company Pinnacle Technologies and later served as chairman and chief executive of Liberty Energy.

2 cases and 3 statements

Andrii Sybiha

Andrii Sybiha is a Ukrainian diplomat who has been Ukraine's minister of foreign affairs since September 2024. He was previously deputy head of the Office of the President of Ukraine, Ukraine's ambassador to Turkey and director of the Foreign Ministry's consular service.

2 cases and 3 statements

David E. Sanger

David E. Sanger is a White House and national security correspondent for The New York Times. He writes about foreign policy, technology and the presidency, contributes analysis to CNN and teaches national security policy at Harvard's Kennedy School. His books include The Perfect Weapon and New Cold Wars.

1 case and 1 statement

James Stavridis

James Stavridis is a retired U.S. Navy admiral, author and national security analyst. He commanded U.S. Southern Command and was NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe, and later led Tufts University's Fletcher School.

1 case and 1 statement

Dan Negrea

Dan Negrea is a U.S. diplomat and former Wall Street investment banker. He is the U.S. representative to the UN Economic and Social Council and an alternate representative to the UN General Assembly, and in the first Trump administration he was a senior policy planning adviser and then special representative for commercial and business affairs at the State Department.

1 case and 1 statement

Andriy Melnyk

Andriy Melnyk is a Ukrainian diplomat who has been Ukraine's permanent representative to the United Nations since May 2025. He was Ukraine's ambassador to Germany from 2014 to 2022, deputy foreign minister from 2022 to 2023 and ambassador to Brazil from 2023 to 2025.

1 case and 1 statement

Michael McFaul

Michael McFaul is a professor of political science at Stanford University and a senior fellow at its Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies and the Hoover Institution. He served as U.S. ambassador to Russia from 2012 to 2014, after three years on the National Security Council staff.

3 cases and 4 statements

Dmitry Peskov

Dmitry Peskov is the Press Secretary of the President of Russia and Deputy Chief of the Presidential Executive Office, posts he has held since May 21, 2012. A graduate of Moscow State University's Institute of Asian and African Countries, he worked at the Soviet and Russian foreign ministry and at the embassy in Ankara, joined the president's press service in 2000, and was press secretary to the prime minister from 2008 to 2012.

3 cases and 3 statements

More people