Luke Plunkett is an Australian games journalist, critic and author based in Canberra. He wrote for Kotaku for 17 years before leaving in July 2023 to help launch Aftermath, an independent, worker-owned website about video games and their culture, which he co-founded. He has also written a book about cosplay.
Role at the time: Aftermath co-founder, writing a column on Aftermath
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Writing in Aftermath, Plunkett says Steam's AI disclosures exist so players can choose not to spend time and money on games that use the technology. He says the number of games on Steam that plainly use AI-generated imagery without disclosing it is getting out of control, and that Valve enforcing its own guidelines would be a start.
“Those disclosures are there precisely so I can exercise my preferences as a consumer to not give my time and money to projects that are making wilful and repeated use of a technology that is already having serious environmental, creative, societal, economic and cognitive effects.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Why Are Games Hiding Their Blatant AI Usage If They Think It's Totally Cool And Fine And The FutureParagraph on what the disclosures are for
Why we used this label
Plunkett defends the disclosures as the information players need to avoid AI-made games and asks Valve to enforce them, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Valve shows AI-generated content disclosures on Steam store pages so players can see how games use AI. Tim Sweeney calls the requirement irresponsible and harmful to developers, while composer Joris de Man and developer Mike Bithell say players should be told.