Debbie Dingell says Flock cameras need serious guardrails
Debbie DingellU.S. Representative for Michigan's 6th district, in a campaign newsletter her campaign sent to Dispute Index
In a campaign newsletter section her campaign sent to Dispute Index on November 19, 2026, Rep. Debbie Dingell, a Michigan Democrat, says license-plate cameras can help law enforcement but asks who can access the data, how long it is kept and whether it can be shared or sold. She calls for serious guardrails on Flock cameras and national privacy rules.
“The Flock camera debate may finally be the catalyst that makes Americans understand the magnitude of privacy issues. Automated license-plate readers can create records of where vehicles were seen, when they were seen, and where they traveled. The question isn’t simply whether these cameras can help law enforcement. They can. The question is: What are the rules? Who can access the information? How long is it kept? Can it be shared? Can it be sold? Can innocent people’s movements be tracked and reconstructed? We should be able to protect public safety without turning America into a place where everyone’s movements are permanently recorded.”
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Emailed statement
Read the full email
Flock Cameras It is long past time for Congress to act on privacy. I have been trying to get privacy legislation done for years. At times, colleagues thought I was sitting up at night imagining scenarios that could never happen. I wasn’t. I worked in the auto industry. I knew what the technology was capable of, and I knew where it was headed. And the current discussion about Flock cameras is necessary. The Flock camera debate may finally be the catalyst that makes Americans understand the magnitude of privacy issues. Automated license-plate readers can create records of where vehicles were seen, when they were seen, and where they traveled. The question isn’t simply whether these cameras can help law enforcement. They can. The question is: What are the rules? Who can access the information? How long is it kept? Can it be shared? Can it be sold? Can innocent people’s movements be tracked and reconstructed? We should be able to protect public safety without turning America into a place where everyone’s movements are permanently recorded. The General Motors data collection is a perfect example. GM had information about driver’s behavior—including things like speeding, hard braking and acceleration—which they collected without most drivers knowing or being aware. And even worse, it was shared. The information was provided to consumer reporting agencies, and insurance companies used data from those reports in decisions about drivers. Some saw their insurance rates go up. Think about that. You could be driving your own car, paying for your own car, and have no idea that information about how you drive is being collected, sold or used to determine what you pay for insurance. And this is just the beginning. We are surrounded by technology that collects information about us. Our phones know where we go. Apps know what we search for and buy. Websites track what we read and watch. Smart devices can collect information about our homes. Our cars can record where we travel and how we drive. Taken individually, each piece of information may seem harmless. But put them together and they can create an extraordinarily detailed picture of your life. They can reveal where you work, where you worship, where you receive medical care, where you shop, what you eat and drink, who your friends are, where you travel, what you read, what you buy, what time you leave your house and even how fast you drive. And that is where the real danger lies. Information is power. The more information someone has about you, the more they can potentially predict your behavior, influence your choices or make decisions about you. And you may never know that it is happening. It is also a very big security risk which most don’t think about. The more personal information companies and governments accumulate, the more valuable those databases become to hackers, criminals and foreign governments. A breach could expose far more than a password—it could expose a map of someone’s life. Sometimes, without thinking about it or knowing potential consequences, you agree to data being shared. But you should also think about the fact that when information is collected, you cannot assume it will always be used for the purpose you were told about when you agreed to share it. Companies change. Technology changes. Data can be sold, transferred, combined with other databases or analyzed in ways that nobody anticipated when it was first collected. This should particularly concern young people. Many have grown up believing that sharing personal information online is simply part of life. They may not realize that something they post, search, click on or allow an app to collect today can remain available for years—and potentially come back to affect their employment, finances, insurance, reputation, or relationships. I don’t want people knowing my life. I don’t want a company—or the government—to know what I eat, what I drink, where I go, who my friends are, where I worship, where I receive medical care, what I read, what I buy, or how fast I drive. That isn’t because I have something to hide. It is because privacy is part of freedom. For years, I have warned that technology was moving faster than our laws. Some thought the scenarios I raised were far-fetched. They weren’t then and aren’t now. What we have now is concrete evidence of how data is being used. Congress needs to establish clear national privacy protections—what can be collected, what requires consent, who can access it, how long it can be retained, whether it can be sold or shared, and what rights individuals have over their own information. Because the question isn’t whether we have something to hide. The question is whether we should have the right to control who knows our lives. To the young people who think it doesn’t matter, George Orwell wrote the novel 1984 as a warning. If you haven’t read it, I suggest you do. And to those of us who have, rereading it will have a different meaning now. We need to make sure it doesn’t become our reality simply because we failed to write the rules in time. And every community should think long and hard about Flock cameras and the need for serious guardrails.

Where this statement fits
Should Flock-style license-plate surveillance networks exist?
Networked automated license-plate readers record passing vehicles and let agencies search or share travel records across locations. Candidates and officials disagree over whether to prohibit these networks, keep them with legal limits, or defend their use for investigations. This tracker records attributable positions on that choice, including proposals that would affect only public funding or data access.
Source and context
Emailed statement
Debbie Dingell campaign newsletter section on Flock cameras, emailed to Dispute Index
Flock Cameras It is long past time for Congress to act on privacy. I have been trying to get privacy legislation done for years. At times, colleagues thought I was sitting up at night imagining scenarios that could never happen. I wasn’t. I worked in the auto industry. I knew what the technology was capable of, and I knew where it was headed. And the current discussion about Flock cameras is necessary. The Flock camera debate may finally be the catalyst that makes Americans understand the magnitude of privacy issues. Automated license-plate readers can create records of where vehicles were seen, when they were seen, and where they traveled. The question isn’t simply whether these cameras can help law enforcement. They can. The question is: What are the rules? Who can access the information? How long is it kept? Can it be shared? Can it be sold? Can innocent people’s movements be tracked and reconstructed? We should be able to protect public safety without turning America into a place where everyone’s movements are permanently recorded. The General Motors data collection is a perfect example. GM had information about driver’s behavior—including things like speeding, hard braking and acceleration—which they collected without most drivers knowing or being aware. And even worse, it was shared. The information was provided to consumer reporting agencies, and insurance companies used data from those reports in decisions about drivers. Some saw their insurance rates go up. Think about that. You could be driving your own car, paying for your own car, and have no idea that information about how you drive is being collected, sold or used to determine what you pay for insurance. And this is just the beginning. We are surrounded by technology that collects information about us. Our phones know where we go. Apps know what we search for and buy. Websites track what we read and watch. Smart devices can collect information about our homes. Our cars can record where we travel and how we drive. Taken individually, each piece of information may seem harmless. But put them together and they can create an extraordinarily detailed picture of your life. They can reveal where you work, where you worship, where you receive medical care, where you shop, what you eat and drink, who your friends are, where you travel, what you read, what you buy, what time you leave your house and even how fast you drive. And that is where the real danger lies. Information is power. The more information someone has about you, the more they can potentially predict your behavior, influence your choices or make decisions about you. And you may never know that it is happening. It is also a very big security risk which most don’t think about. The more personal information companies and governments accumulate, the more valuable those databases become to hackers, criminals and foreign governments. A breach could expose far more than a password—it could expose a map of someone’s life. Sometimes, without thinking about it or knowing potential consequences, you agree to data being shared. But you should also think about the fact that when information is collected, you cannot assume it will always be used for the purpose you were told about when you agreed to share it. Companies change. Technology changes. Data can be sold, transferred, combined with other databases or analyzed in ways that nobody anticipated when it was first collected. This should particularly concern young people. Many have grown up believing that sharing personal information online is simply part of life. They may not realize that something they post, search, click on or allow an app to collect today can remain available for years—and potentially come back to affect their employment, finances, insurance, reputation, or relationships. I don’t want people knowing my life. I don’t want a company—or the government—to know what I eat, what I drink, where I go, who my friends are, where I worship, where I receive medical care, what I read, what I buy, or how fast I drive. That isn’t because I have something to hide. It is because privacy is part of freedom. For years, I have warned that technology was moving faster than our laws. Some thought the scenarios I raised were far-fetched. They weren’t then and aren’t now. What we have now is concrete evidence of how data is being used. Congress needs to establish clear national privacy protections—what can be collected, what requires consent, who can access it, how long it can be retained, whether it can be sold or shared, and what rights individuals have over their own information. Because the question isn’t whether we have something to hide. The question is whether we should have the right to control who knows our lives. To the young people who think it doesn’t matter, George Orwell wrote the novel 1984 as a warning. If you haven’t read it, I suggest you do. And to those of us who have, rereading it will have a different meaning now. We need to make sure it doesn’t become our reality simply because we failed to write the rules in time. And every community should think long and hard about Flock cameras and the need for serious guardrails.
About this source
Emailed reply from a staff member of Debbie Dingell for Congress to a Dispute Index question on Flock-style license plate camera networks. The campaign said the text comes from a newsletter Dingell sent in August 2026; we could not locate a public copy of the newsletter.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Dispute Index asked Dingell's campaign on October 1, 2026, and again on October 19, October 29 and November 18, whether she supports, opposes or wants changes to the use of Flock-style license plate camera networks. A campaign staff member replied on November 19 with the Flock section of a newsletter the campaign said Dingell sent in August.
After the quotation
In the same section, Dingell writes that every community should think long and hard about Flock cameras and the need for serious guardrails.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
This case asks whether networked license-plate reader systems such as Flock should exist and be used. Dingell says the cameras can help law enforcement but that the rules on access, retention, sharing and sale are unsettled, and she calls for serious guardrails, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional with the Guardrails step. She asks Congress for national privacy protections but names no specific limit on the cameras.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseRichard Ojeda opposes Flock cameras, his campaign says
“Representative-elect Ojeda is opposed to Flock Cameras and believes it is a violation of our civil liberties and privacy.”Read statement
Deborah Ross opposes the use of Flock devices, her campaign says
“As a former civil rights attorney and a member of the House Judiciary Committee, Rep. Ross believes the privacy of American citizens is paramount. She opposes the use of Flock devices and believes we can give local law enforcement the resources they need without violating Americans' privacy.”Read statement
Kweisi Mfume says Congress must set clear limits on license plate cameras
“Americans should not have to give up their right to privacy every time they drive down the street. Right now, there are too few safeguards on who can search this data, why, and for how long it is kept. Congress must set clear limits and hold accountable anyone who abuses their access.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Debbie Dingell says Flock cameras need serious guardrails
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/9902-in-a-campaign-newsletter-section-her-campaign-sent
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Debbie Dingell says Flock cameras need serious guardrails". First published: 2026-11-19. Last updated: 2026-11-19. https://disputeindex.com/events/9902-in-a-campaign-newsletter-section-her-campaign-sent