Condemned
“you unilaterally tried to dictate who from other side can stay on the paper”
Argues that the proposed joint-credit arrangement improperly allowed one party to choose which other collaborator would receive authorship.
- Speaker
- Nan Jiang
- Capacity
- Personal response to Bubeck's explanation
- Observed
- September 10, 2026
- Published here
- September 10, 2026
- Classification rationale
- A substantive criticism that survives the distinction between the two teams' proofs.
Surrounding material
Full context
Before the quotation
Responds after the authorship-context clarification.
After the quotation
Explicitly acknowledges in his thread that the proposal concerned OpenAI's work, but maintains the exclusion was objectionable.
Evidence
Complete source record
Nan Jiang challenges the proposed authorship arrangements after Bubeck's clarification (opens in a new tab)
Crucial follow-up explicitly acknowledges that the proposed authorship was on OpenAI's work, while maintaining his criticism of excluding the other collaborator.