Sen. Kaine says a review of classified records suggests the strikes killed people not involved in narcotrafficking
Tim KaineU.S. senator from Virginia and member of the Armed Services and Foreign Relations committees, writing to the President
In an August 3 letter to President Trump, Kaine wrote that "a careful review of the available evidence suggests that the United States has killed individuals who are not involved in narcotrafficking" and called them "murder victims".
Responding to
Sen. Tim Kaine wrote on August 3, 2026 that a careful review of the available evidence suggests the United States has killed individuals who were not involved in narcotrafficking, and his office said the administration has not provided evidence that the vessels it targets were narcotraffickers.
“My review of your directive, the OLC legal opinion, the EXORD, and the notifications of the boat strikes, makes clear that the United States is engaged in violent and fatal attacks against people far beyond those whom the OLC opinion claimed could be lawfully targeted. In other words, a careful review of the available evidence suggests that the United States has killed individuals who are not involved in narcotrafficking. They are murder victims.”
Official statement
Where this statement fits
Was the U.S. military's September 19 Caribbean boat strike justified by evidence of narcotics trafficking?
On September 19, 2026, U.S. Southern Command announced that Joint Task Force Western Hemisphere had struck a go-fast vessel in the Caribbean Sea and killed four people it called "narco-terrorists". The command said "Confirmed intelligence revealed the vessel's active involvement in narco-trafficking". According to The Associated Press, the military did not provide evidence that the vessel was carrying drugs. On September 20, U.N. Special Rapporteur Ben Saul posted a briefing note concluding that U.S. strikes on alleged drug boats since September 2025 amount to "serial extrajudicial killings" and that there are "reasonable grounds to believe" the 68 attacks he counted through August 2026 "constituted crimes against humanity of murder". White House spokesperson Anna Kelly said on September 22 that the strikes have been "against designated narcoterrorists". The dispute is whether the intelligence Southern Command cites, which it did not release with its announcement, justified the September 19 strike.
Source and context
Official statement
About this source
Sen. Kaine's press release and letter to President Trump. The letter describes his review of the President's directive, a Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel opinion, the Defense Department order and the classified notifications to Congress about the strikes.
Before the quotation
The letter predates the September 19 strike by nearly seven weeks. Kaine wrote after reviewing the President's directive, a Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel opinion, the Defense Department order implementing the directive and the classified notifications to Congress about the strikes.
After the quotation
Kaine's office said the administration has not provided evidence to support its claims that the targeted vessels were narcotraffickers.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Measured against the campaign the September 19 strike belongs to and the government's stated basis that those aboard are narcotraffickers, Kaine says his review indicates otherwise and calls the dead "murder victims", which is an express condemnation.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseRachel VanLandingham says international condemnation makes it clearer the boat strikes are unlawful
“For the vast majority of service members, except perhaps the senior-most commanders, there is both no safe recourse for them to disobey orders related to the illegal boat strikes and at the same time, there is no exposure to criminal liability for them either … Yes, the growing international condemnation makes it clearer that these strikes are unlawful, but doesn’t overcome the White House’s own legal sanitization process and doesn’t create a legal duty for any service member to disobey their boat strike-related orders”Read statement
Southern Command tells Task & Purpose its operations have been conducted lawfully
U.S. Southern Command
“have been conducted lawfully, fully complying with the law of armed conflict”Read statement
Chuy Garcia calls the Caribbean and Pacific boat strikes illegal extrajudicial killings
“Donald Trump is dropping bombs across the Caribbean and Pacific in blatant violation of the law and of fundamental human rights … This has done nothing to stop the flow of drugs or to make Americans safer. Instead, it has left hundreds dead, families devastated, and communities in fear. Let us call these attacks what they are: illegal extrajudicial killings.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Sen. Kaine says a review of classified records suggests the strikes killed people not involved in narcotrafficking
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/2656-in-an-august-3-letter-to-president-trump
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Sen. Kaine says a review of classified records suggests the strikes killed people not involved in narcotrafficking". First published: 2026-09-26. Last updated: 2026-09-26. https://disputeindex.com/events/2656-in-an-august-3-letter-to-president-trump