Bonta says the sheriff misused investigative tools and defied his request to pause

Rob BontaCalifornia Attorney General; petitioner in Bonta v. Bianco and amicus curiae in Cervantes v. Bianco

Condemned

Attorney General Rob Bonta said election fraud can be investigated but that misusing criminal investigative tools without evidence of a crime undermines trust, and that after he asked Sheriff Bianco to pause and preserve evidence, Bianco "pressed forward" with the seizure. He said the court had made clear that "this kind of defiance cannot stand" and that voted ballots belong in the custody of elections officials.

Responding to

The Attorney General's constitutional and statutory supervisory authority over sheriffs includes the power to give binding directions about a criminal investigation, including to preserve seized items and pause the investigation, and Sheriff Bianco was required to comply.

“Election fraud can and should be investigated. But misuse of criminal investigative tools — without any evidence that a crime was committed — needlessly undermines trust in our elections system and in law enforcement. After the Sheriff took the extraordinary step of obtaining warrants to seize control over voted ballots, I made a modest request to him: pause your investigation, preserve all evidence, and provide the information needed for my office to review the allegations. Instead, Sheriff Bianco pressed forward with the seizure of hundreds of thousands of ballots. The Court has now made clear that this kind of defiance cannot stand, that the Attorney General has the authority to intervene when sheriffs take improper action, and that voted ballots belong in the custody of elections officials.”

Official statement

Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Attorney General Bonta Secures Major Victories from State's Highest Court, Confirming Authority to Issue Binding Directives to Riverside Sheriff and Ordering Sheriff to Return Voted Ballots to the Registrar of Voters · Rob BontaPress release, statement of Attorney General Rob Bonta

Case updates

Updates on the Riverside ballot seizure after the court's ruling

Get notified if new court filings follow the California Supreme Court's ruling, Bianco takes further steps in his inquiry, or state officials respond.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

Editorial composite of Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco beside the California Supreme Court opinion in the ballot-seizure case.
Credit: Riverside County Sheriff's Office; Supreme Court of California; composite by The Dispute Index

Where this statement fits

Was Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco's seizure of about 650,000 ballots lawful?

Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco's department obtained search warrants in February and March 2026 and, on February 26, seized about 650,000 ballots from the November 2025 Proposition 50 special election from the county registrar of voters. Bianco said he was investigating a discrepancy of 45,896 ballots reported by a citizens' group; Registrar Art Tinoco said the reported gap reflected a misreading of preliminary records and that the actual variance was 103 ballots. Attorney General Rob Bonta directed Bianco on February 26 to preserve the materials and pause the investigation, and sued after Bianco said on March 20 that it would continue despite the Attorney General's attempts to stop it. On September 24, 2026, the California Supreme Court unanimously held in Cervantes v. Bianco that the seizure violated Elections Code section 15551(d) and ordered the ballots returned, and held in Bonta v. Bianco that the Attorney General may give a sheriff binding directions about an investigation. Bianco says the investigation was lawful and that he disagrees with the rulings, but has said he will obey the court's writs; the court did not resolve whether the claimed discrepancy exists.

Read the full case

Source and context

Official statement

Attorney General Bonta Secures Major Victories from State's Highest Court, Confirming Authority to Issue Binding Directives to Riverside Sheriff and Ordering Sheriff to Return Voted Ballots to the Registrar of Voters (opens in a new tab) · Rob BontaPress release, statement of Attorney General Rob Bonta

About this source

Official press release with the Attorney General's statement on the two California Supreme Court decisions in Bonta v. Bianco and Cervantes v. Bianco.

Before the quotation

The statement accompanied the California Supreme Court's two rulings and followed the Attorney General's February 26 directive to Bianco to preserve the seized materials and pause the investigation, which the court held lawful.

After the quotation

The release added that Governor Newsom signed Senate Bill 1418, sponsored by the Attorney General, the previous week to strengthen protections for election materials.

How this statement is classified

Condemned

The label describes this statement's response within the context above.

Why this label?

The reference point is the sheriff's seizure and handling of the ballots. Bonta says the seizure misused criminal investigative tools and that Bianco's refusal to pause was defiance that cannot stand, which expressly rejects the conduct; his statement that fraud can be investigated does not soften that.

Recorded on
Published here
People and groups discussed
Chad Bianco

More from this case

Read the full case

Share or embed this statement

Quote card: Rob Bonta, Bonta says the sheriff misused investigative tools and defied his request to pauseDownload image (PNG)

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Bonta says the sheriff misused investigative tools and defied his request to pause
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/events/2419-attorney-general-rob-bonta-said-election-fraud-can

Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.

The Dispute Index. "Bonta says the sheriff misused investigative tools and defied his request to pause". First published: 2026-09-25. Last updated: 2026-09-25. https://disputeindex.com/events/2419-attorney-general-rob-bonta-said-election-fraud-can