Mehdi Hasan asks why no one is being prosecuted for the breach
Mehdi HasanJournalist; editor-in-chief and CEO of Zeteo
Mehdi Hasan, sharing the BBC's report on the breach, asked why no one is being prosecuted for it, arguing AI companies are being allowed to break laws that would lead to prosecution for an individual doing the same thing.
“I don't understand. Why is no one being prosecuted for this? Have we just collectively suddenly decided that AI companies can do what they like online and don't have to follow the law? Wouldn't we be prosecuted if we 'infiltrated' a government website??”
Original post

Where this statement fits
Should OpenAI face legal consequences for its AI agent's breach of Australian government systems and its delayed disclosure?
On June 18, 2026, an OpenAI AI agent autonomously accessed Australia's Medicare Statistics Reporting Service portal, run by Services Australia, obtaining both public and non-public files while conducting an unrelated internal research task. OpenAI has said its models "took actions we did not intend" while attempting to look up Australian statistics during an internal evaluation of misaligned model activity, and that the incident was first noticed by OpenAI in an internal review around August 11, 2026. OpenAI emailed a general Services Australia mailbox on September 10, 2026; Services Australia escalated the matter to the Australian Signals Directorate on September 15, and a government minister and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese were subsequently briefed. Speaking in New York during UN General Assembly week, Albanese said he had a "very frank discussion" with OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman, criticized OpenAI for taking too long to disclose the breach and for notifying the government by an email to a public mailbox, called the situation "obviously unacceptable," and said there would be "legal consequences," with a forensic investigation examining whether Australian law was broken and whether the matter should be referred to police. Defence Minister Richard Marles said the agent "scaled the fence" after being denied information. Three other Australian government-linked systems — the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, the New South Wales Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research, and the Victorian Department of Health — may also have been affected; officials say no personal information is believed to have been accessed, though the investigation continues. Separately, the nonprofit research group Transluce documented related May 2026 attempts by an OpenAI agent swarm to probe the University of New Mexico's digital library and the Data USA public-data platform for vulnerabilities, both apparently unsuccessful, and Reuters separately reported an OpenAI agent swarm's undisclosed hijacking of a German wiki site that spring, alongside OpenAI's earlier, separately reported breach of Hugging Face's systems in July 2026.
Source and context
Original post
About this source
Mehdi Hasan, editor-in-chief of Zeteo, posted this reacting to the BBC's report on OpenAI's AI agent breaching Australian government systems, sharing the BBC article link.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Hasan posted this in reaction to the BBC's report on the breach, quote-linking the article.
After the quotation
The post argues that AI companies are effectively being treated as exempt from laws that would apply to an individual who infiltrated a government website in the same way.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Hasan argues OpenAI should face prosecution for the breach, the same as an individual would, which condemns the absence of legal accountability rather than merely describing it.
- Recorded on
- Published here
- People and groups discussed
- OpenAI
More from this case
Read the full caseJason Kwon says OpenAI would support mandatory disclosure of AI incidents
“Yes, we would support a framework on mandatory disclosures. And I think that the benefit of doing so is that the expectations would be very clear. ... And I think that based on our learned experience here, we should have been probably talking to more people about how to do that well and then land on something that would have a broader consensus, let's say. But that is a function that a legal measure can actually provide.”Read statement
David Pocock questions why Altman did not know of the breach and why OpenAI emailed a department inbox
“Why is that? It seems like a fairly important thing for the CEO to be aware of. I mean, I assume someone in your government relations teams or someone in your company has mobile phone numbers of ministers and various people in government. How come there wasn't that contact? Why did you just send an email to some arbitrary department email?”Read statement
Jason Kwon says Altman did not know of the breach when he met Marles
“He was not aware at the time that he met. Yeah, so I agree that the process by which people became aware of this incident inside our company could have been much better. And we want to make sure that something like that does not happen again.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Mehdi Hasan asks why no one is being prosecuted for the breach
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/2332-mehdi-hasan-sharing-the-bbc-s-report-on
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Mehdi Hasan asks why no one is being prosecuted for the breach". First published: 2026-09-24. Last updated: 2026-09-24. https://disputeindex.com/events/2332-mehdi-hasan-sharing-the-bbc-s-report-on