Anjali Dayal says the Greenland announcement looks like NATO membership terms restated to Trump
Associate professor of international politics at Fordham University, on her personal Bluesky account
“I know this is alarming people, but it looks to me like someone just restated the terms of NATO membership to him”
Source and context
Original post
About this source
Dayal's own Bluesky post (@anjalikdayal.bsky.social, DID did:plc:wqhbdx55f4vv7bnpps5pur4c), a quote-post of Aaron Rupar's post (https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mvt42eegvc27, 5:22 PM EDT), which carries a screenshot of Trump's Truth Social announcement and one quoted line of it. Read through the public Bluesky API (getPostThread): record.createdAt 2026-09-18T21:29:23.730Z = 5:29 PM EDT. The quotation is the text field of Dayal's own record; the quoted post's words are Rupar's and Trump's. "Him" in the post refers to Trump (her same-thread reply speaks of restating agreements "you've already made to him as though they're new breakthroughs he's made"). It was the most-liked of 319 quote-posts of Rupar's post that were retrieved (1,104 likes at check time). Not archived: Wayback Machine lookups were throttled and Bluesky pages are client-rendered.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Original post
About this source
Her own reply in the same thread, read through the Bluesky API (getPostThread). Used only as context for what followed her post; it is not part of the quotation.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Original post
About this source
Her own later reply in the same thread, read through the Bluesky API (getPostThread). Used only as context for what followed her post; it is not part of the quotation.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Original text
About this source
Read in full on the trumpstruth.org archive mirror, which shows the full text, the original post date (Friday, September 18, 2026, 05:18 pm EDT), the Truth Social status ID and the original URL https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/117294126158197822; truthsocial.com itself is Cloudflare-blocked and was not opened. The post says the United States “has entered into an Agreement,” whereas the Danish and Greenlandic release describes an expected agreement still to be signed. The identical text was posted on Trump’s X account (separate source). This page was captured by the mirror on September 19, 2026 at 11:51 AM EDT; the mirror’s later Truth Social entries through 12:52 PM EDT that day, including the transcript of a 1:06 AM video, do not mention Greenland.
Official statement
About this source
Official English version of the joint press release, dated 9/18/2026 (no time shown on the page). The Prime Minister's Office announced it on X at 2026-09-18 21:37:58 UTC (5:37 PM EDT; https://x.com/Statsmin/status/2101063203862057308, timestamp decoded from the post ID and confirmed through fxtwitter). Danish original: https://stm.dk/presse/pressemeddelelser/forventet-aftale-om-styrket-sikkerhed-i-arktis-og-det-nordatlantiske-omraade/ , where the Frederiksen quotation reads "udsigt til en god aftale" (the prospect of a good agreement) whereas the English version says "a great agreement". The release describes an expected agreement; it does not publish the text.
Reporting
About this source
AP wire report as carried by ABC News, published 2026-09-19 5:37 AM EDT (09:37 UTC), last modified 16:10 UTC. Opened in full. Used only for two context facts: the agreement text was not public, and the U.S. and Denmark already had a long-standing security agreement (AP's wording for the 1951 Defense of Greenland accord). The same AP text is carried by CBS News (cbsnews.com/news/denmark-greenland-leaders-us-security-deal-trump/). A news search on 2026-09-19 found no report that the text had been published since.
Before the quotation
At 5:18 p.m. EDT on September 18, 2026, President Trump posted on Truth Social that the United States had entered an agreement with Denmark and Greenland "that gives the United States permanent control over security, and all other needs, in Greenland." Dayal's post quoted a Bluesky post by journalist Aaron Rupar that reproduced Trump's announcement as an image.
After the quotation
In replies in the same thread she called this "a canny strategy" of restating agreements already made to Trump as though they were new breakthroughs, and wrote that she did not mean it "absolves him of his threats to Greenland" but that it is "an impressive diplomatic effort from Denmark and Greenland." Later that day, the Danish Prime Minister's Office and the Government of Greenland issued a joint press release describing an expected agreement, and the Associated Press reported on September 19 that the agreement's text had not been made public.
How this statement is classified
Case context: Trump’s “permanent control” description of the announced U.S.-Denmark-Greenland security agreement
The label describes this statement’s response within the context above.
Why this label?
The case's fixed reference point is Trump's description, in his September 18 Truth Social post, of the unsigned and unpublished U.S.-Denmark-Greenland agreement as giving the United States permanent control over security and all other needs in Greenland. Dayal acknowledges that the announcement is alarming people, then says it looks to her as though someone restated the terms of NATO membership to Trump, which disputes that the agreement is new without condemning or endorsing it. The closest competing label is minimizes, because the opening acknowledges alarm and a restatement of existing terms would also mean little has changed. That loses because the passage makes a claim about what the announcement describes, not about how serious its consequences would be.
- Recorded on
- Published here
- People and groups discussed
- Donald Trump
Trump’s “permanent control” description of the announced U.S.-Denmark-Greenland security agreement
Explore the case context, sources and public responses.
More from this case
Read the full case“I'm looking forward to the ink being dry on the new agreement with the USA. And to us being able to see the content. Until then, I'm skeptical. I don't have much confidence in Trump.”Read statement
“We will have to wait with that until the agreement is published next week. So I don't have many comments on that.”Read statement
“Next week could be a good week… For Greenland, Denmark and the USA alike. Where a long period of uncertainty is hopefully replaced by a binding agreement that strengthens security in the Arctic and the North Atlantic and thus also our shared security in NATO and Europe - with respect for the Kingdom's red lines.”Read statement