Jesse Watters says "free Palestine" isn't hate speech, but Kraft can still ban him
Jesse WattersFox News host, co-host of "The Five"
On the September 15 broadcast of Fox News's "The Five," Jesse Watters questioned why Macklemore's "free Palestine" remark was being treated as hate speech, saying that's all he heard Macklemore say and he did not think it qualified. He then said Robert Kraft was within his rights to bar Macklemore from his venue regardless, comparing it to how he would remove anyone annoying or political from his own hypothetical tour.
“So what did he say that was bad? He said, free Palestine? Is that all? Okay, all I heard was free Palestine. I don't think that's hate speech... You know, if Rob Kraft doesn't want you there, he owns the venue, you're gone, who cares? Who cares?! If Greg's on my tour and he's spouting off and annoying me, I'm giving him the boot. I don't even care if it's political. If he even looks at me the wrong way if I take him on tour, he is gone.”
Reporting

Where this statement fits
Macklemore’s “Free Palestine” speech and removal from Ed Sheeran’s U.S. tour
At two Ed Sheeran concerts at MetLife Stadium, Macklemore called for a free Palestine, accused Israel of apartheid and genocide, and said criticism of Israel was not criticism of Jewish people. After venue objections, tour promoter Messina Touring Group said he would not perform the remaining U.S. Loop Tour dates. Critics characterized the performance as hostile or inappropriate; Macklemore defended it as a call for equal treatment.
Source and context
Reporting
About this source
Mediaite's report on the Tuesday, September 15, 2026 broadcast of Fox News's "The Five," quoting Watters directly. The Fox News episode itself is paywalled on foxnews.com with no free clip. Quotation independently corroborated: HasanAbi replayed the same clip with matching wording on a September 17, 2026 YouTube video, and Watters's remarks were also reported by Yahoo Entertainment, TVInsider and HuffPost with consistent quotations.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Kraft had said Macklemore was barred from Gillette Stadium over "a broader history of antisemitic rhetoric and imagery" and material shared from the stage during the New Jersey shows; the tour promoter said venues would not host a concert with Macklemore on the lineup.
After the quotation
Watters's co-hosts on "The Five" spoke over him in response, saying Macklemore's remarks were more extreme than the free-Palestine line alone. Hasan Piker replayed the clip approvingly on his September 17 YouTube show, framing it as evidence that "even Fox News" recognized the removal as excessive, though the clip itself does not go that far.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Watters takes two materially different positions on the two parts of that. On the speech itself, he rejects the "hate speech" characterization and says he heard nothing objectionable, which favors Macklemore. On the removal, he does not criticize it at all; he affirmatively defends Kraft's prerogative to exclude Macklemore from the venue regardless of the reason, comparing it to ejecting anyone who annoys him. That is a defense of the conduct under scrutiny, not a condemnation of it. The closest competing label is condemns, since several outlets framed this as Watters "defending" Macklemore; that framing describes only the first half of the clip. It loses because the second half is an explicit shrug at the removal itself ("who cares?"), which is not a criticism of Kraft's action. “Mixed or conditional” is used because the two positions are about different components of the same conduct under scrutiny and are not reconciled in the clip.
- Recorded on
- Published here
- People and groups discussed
- Robert Kraft
More from this case
Read the full caseMacklemore says the "billionaire class" should not decide "which voices are allowed on stage"
“What happened to me is bigger than one artist or one stage. When the billionaire class can decide which voices are allowed on stage and which ones are too dangerous to hear, everyone should be paying attention. So we're going on tour. All proceeds will benefit organizations supporting the Palestinian people and movement.”Read statement
Jewish Voice for Peace says the backlash to Macklemore's removal shows support for pro-Palestine speech
Jewish Voice for Peace
“Two years into Trump’s crackdown on pro-Palestine organizing, the backlash against Sheeran shows how little patience Americans have for attacks on pro-Palestine speech. It also demonstrates the shift toward support for Palestinian rights among everyday Americans that our movements have helped propel.”Read statement
Macklemore announces "Free Palestine Tour" after removal from U.S. dates
“To push back when the call for a Free Palestine is met with attempts to silence it.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Jesse Watters says "free Palestine" isn't hate speech, but Kraft can still ban him
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/1012-on-the-september-15-broadcast-of-fox-news
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Jesse Watters says "free Palestine" isn't hate speech, but Kraft can still ban him". First published: 2026-09-18. Last updated: 2026-09-22. https://disputeindex.com/events/1012-on-the-september-15-broadcast-of-fox-news