ICE posts a recruitment video promising "the way it can be again"; critics call it racist, and Sierra Ferrell says the agency used her song without permission
ICE posted a recruitment video of midcentury American life captioned "The way it was. The way it can be again." Critics called it racist, singer Sierra Ferrell said it used her song without permission, and the post came down.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
Ferrell, a West Virginia native, won four Grammy Awards in 2025. The Gateway Pundit reports that she has previously given tour proceeds to the National Immigration Law Center.
Other musicians have objected to the use of their songs in government videos about immigration enforcement. The Tennessean reports that Sabrina Carpenter objected to a December 2025 White House video that used one of her songs, and that Olivia Rodrigo and SZA have also objected.
People in this case
Sierra FerrellDirectly involved
David FrenchCommented
Alyssa Farah GriffinCommented
Timeline
3 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 12, 2026 to November 15, 2026
November 2026
ICE posts a recruitment video set to "American Dreaming"
The video pairs footage of American life from about the 1930s to the 1960s with the text "The way it was. The way it can be again. Join ICE."
[01]HuffPost
HuffPost describes ICE's November 12 recruitment video, set to Sierra Ferrell's "American Dreaming," and collects reactions from Alyssa Farah Griffin, Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, Maria Cardona and others.
Critics Slam New WTF Ad From ICE: 'They're Literally Copying Third Reich Propaganda' · HuffPostArticle, November 13, 2026[02]Mediaite
Mediaite describes the scenes and on-screen text of ICE's recruitment video and quotes the X posts of David French, Maria Cardona, Aaron Reichlin-Melnick and Alyssa Farah Griffin.
Critics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was' · MediaiteArticle, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)Sierra Ferrell says ICE used her song without permission
Ferrell says she found the video genuinely racist, that her team has moved to have the ads taken down and that she is weighing legal action.
[03]Sierra Ferrell
Ferrell posts a written statement saying ICE used her song without permission, that she found the video racist, and that her team has moved to have the ads taken down.
Sierra Ferrell's X post on ICE's use of "American Dreaming" · Sierra FerrellPost with an image of a written statement[04]'I do not stand for this': Singer Sierra Ferrell condemns ICE for using her song 'American Dreaming' in controversial promotional video
Hindustan Times quotes Ferrell's full statement and describes the scenes and text of the ICE video.
ICE's post with the video is no longer on X
The Gateway Pundit reports that the post had been removed by Saturday night, November 14, and The Tennessean reports that the video was taken down after Ferrell's statement. ICE has not said why.
[05]The Gateway Pundit
The Gateway Pundit calls the reaction to the ad a meltdown, quotes Ferrell's statement and reports that ICE's post with the video had been removed.
Grammy Winner Sierra Ferrell Throws Fit After ICE Uses Her Song in Epic 'The Way It Was' Ad, Threatens Lawsuit · The Gateway PunditArticle, November 15, 2026[06]ICE removes video after Grammy winner Sierra Ferrell rebukes the use of her song
The Tennessean reports that ICE's video was taken down after Ferrell's statement and lists other musicians who have objected to the use of their songs in government videos.
ICE removes video after Grammy winner Sierra Ferrell rebukes the use of her songArticle, November 16, 2026
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
What is disputed
Critics noted that everyone shown in the video was white. ICE has not publicly responded, and The Gateway Pundit called the criticism a meltdown over white families.
Sources (3)
- Sierra Ferrell's X post on ICE's use of "American Dreaming" · Sierra FerrellPost with an image of a written statement
- Critics Slam New WTF Ad From ICE: 'They're Literally Copying Third Reich Propaganda' · HuffPostArticle, November 13, 2026
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
6 responses. Newest first.
The Gateway PunditRight-wing news and opinion website, in an article by Cassandra MacDonald Before this statement
The article describes the video as showing classic cars, a mother pushing a stroller, Mount Rushmore and families enjoying everyday scenes from better days.
"The left melted down over the ad because it featured white families."
Challenged the characterizationResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
The Gateway Pundit describes the video as showing families enjoying everyday scenes from better days and says the left melted down over it because it featured white families.
After the statement
It reports that ICE had not responded to Ferrell and that the post with the video had been removed.
Grammy Winner Sierra Ferrell Throws Fit After ICE Uses Her Song in Epic 'The Way It Was' Ad, Threatens Lawsuit · The Gateway PunditArticle, November 15, 2026Why this label?
The Gateway Pundit says critics melted down only because the ad featured white families, disputing that the ad is racist, so we labeled it Challenged the characterization.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sierra FerrellSinger-songwriter whose song "American Dreaming" was used in the video, in a statement posted on XDirectly involvedBefore this statement
ICE posted the recruitment video, set to "American Dreaming," on its X account on Thursday.
"On Thursday, ICE used my song “American Dreaming” without permission in a video I found genuinely racist that was pushing a warped view of who belongs in this country"
CondemnedResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
Ferrell says ICE used her song without permission in a video she found genuinely racist, that her team has moved to have the ads taken down and is weighing legal action, and that people are called to support their immigrant neighbors.
After the statement
She said her team had taken steps to have the ads taken down and was weighing legal action for infringing on her rights.
Sierra Ferrell's X post on ICE's use of "American Dreaming" · Sierra FerrellPost with an image of a written statement'I do not stand for this': Singer Sierra Ferrell condemns ICE for using her song 'American Dreaming' in controversial promotional videoArticle, November 15, 2026Grammy Winner Sierra Ferrell Throws Fit After ICE Uses Her Song in Epic 'The Way It Was' Ad, Threatens Lawsuit · The Gateway PunditArticle, November 15, 2026Why this label?
Ferrell calls the video genuinely racist and says it pushes a warped view of who belongs in the country, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Maria CardonaDemocratic strategist and CNN political commentator, in a post on X Before this statement
Mediaite reports that Cardona was responding to ICE's recruitment video.
"Wow! This is one of the most offensive, racist, xenophobic, dog whistle for white nationalists propaganda I have ever seen coming out of an official US government account!"
CondemnedResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
Cardona calls the video one of the most offensive, racist and xenophobic pieces of propaganda she has seen from an official government account and says it will help Democrats in 2028.
After the statement
She added that the country had just elected a historic number of Black, Latino and Native American Democrats.
Maria Cardona's X post on ICE's recruitment video · Maria CardonaQuote postCritics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was' · MediaiteArticle, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)Why this label?
Cardona calls the video racist and xenophobic propaganda, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
David FrenchNew York Times opinion columnist, in a post on XBefore this statement
Mediaite quotes French's post among the critics' reactions to ICE's recruitment video, which pairs footage of American life from the 1930s and 1950s with an invitation to join ICE.
"What about this is supposed to be appealing? The old cars? The crappy old strollers? Old cheap motels and strip malls? Oh I get it. It’s the whiteness. That’s what they want."
CondemnedResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
French asks what about the video is supposed to be appealing, lists its old cars, strollers and motels, and concludes that the appeal is the whiteness.
After the statement
Mediaite reports that writer Charlotte Clymer shared French's post with her own comment on the video.
David French's X post on ICE's recruitment video · David FrenchQuote postCritics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was' · MediaiteArticle, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)Why this label?
French says the video's appeal is its whiteness and that whiteness is what its makers want, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Alyssa Farah GriffinCo-host of The View and former White House communications director, in a post on XBefore this statement
Mediaite and HuffPost report that Griffin was responding to ICE's recruitment video.
"Another reason the GOP lost big in the midterms? This nonsense. Do they realize tens of millions of Americans and voting republicans are descendants of non-white immigrants? It doesn’t make us any less American."
CondemnedResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
Griffin calls the video nonsense and another reason the GOP lost big in the midterms, saying tens of millions of Americans are descendants of non-white immigrants and are no less American.
After the statement
HuffPost notes that Trump said after the midterms that his deportation agenda was too tough and had hurt his party.
Alyssa Farah Griffin's X post on ICE's recruitment video · Alyssa Farah GriffinQuote postCritics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was' · MediaiteArticle, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)Critics Slam New WTF Ad From ICE: 'They're Literally Copying Third Reich Propaganda' · HuffPostArticle, November 13, 2026Why this label?
Griffin calls the video nonsense and says descendants of non-white immigrants are no less American, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Aaron Reichlin-MelnickSenior fellow at the American Immigration Council, in a post on X Before this statement
Mediaite reports that Reichlin-Melnick was responding to ICE's recruitment video.
"Nostalgiaslop for people who think the U.S. was great when Jim Crow was still around."
CondemnedResponding to: ICE's November 12 recruitment video, which presents midcentury America as the way the country can be again, is racist.
Full statement and sources
Reichlin-Melnick says the video is nostalgia aimed at people who think the U.S. was great when Jim Crow laws were in force.
After the statement
Critics noted that Jim Crow laws enforcing racial segregation were in effect during the period the video presents as a model.
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick's X post on ICE's recruitment video · Aaron Reichlin-MelnickQuote postCritics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was' · MediaiteArticle, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)Why this label?
Reichlin-Melnick says the video appeals to people who miss the era of Jim Crow, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(10)
Reporting
Critics Slam New WTF Ad From ICE: 'They're Literally Copying Third Reich Propaganda'
Relevant passage: Article, November 13, 2026
About this source
HuffPost describes ICE's November 12 recruitment video, set to Sierra Ferrell's "American Dreaming," and collects reactions from Alyssa Farah Griffin, Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, Maria Cardona and others.
- Author
- Marco Margaritoff
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ICE removes video after Grammy winner Sierra Ferrell rebukes the use of her song
Relevant passage: Article, November 16, 2026
About this source
The Tennessean reports that ICE's video was taken down after Ferrell's statement and lists other musicians who have objected to the use of their songs in government videos.
- Author
- Peter Burditt
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Grammy Winner Sierra Ferrell Throws Fit After ICE Uses Her Song in Epic 'The Way It Was' Ad, Threatens Lawsuit
Relevant passage: Article, November 15, 2026
About this source
The Gateway Pundit calls the reaction to the ad a meltdown, quotes Ferrell's statement and reports that ICE's post with the video had been removed.
- Author
- Cassandra MacDonald
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
'I do not stand for this': Singer Sierra Ferrell condemns ICE for using her song 'American Dreaming' in controversial promotional video
Relevant passage: Article, November 15, 2026
About this source
Hindustan Times quotes Ferrell's full statement and describes the scenes and text of the ICE video.
- Author
- Sumanti Sen
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Sierra Ferrell's X post on ICE's use of "American Dreaming"
About this source
Ferrell posts a written statement saying ICE used her song without permission, that she found the video racist, and that her team has moved to have the ads taken down.
- Author
- Sierra Ferrell
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Maria Cardona's X post on ICE's recruitment video
About this source
Cardona calls the video offensive, racist and xenophobic propaganda from an official government account.
- Author
- Maria Cardona
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Alyssa Farah Griffin's X post on ICE's recruitment video
About this source
Griffin calls the video another reason the GOP lost the midterms and says descendants of non-white immigrants are no less American.
- Author
- Alyssa Farah Griffin
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick's X post on ICE's recruitment video
About this source
Reichlin-Melnick calls the video nostalgia for people who think the U.S. was great when Jim Crow was still around.
- Author
- Aaron Reichlin-Melnick
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
David French's X post on ICE's recruitment video
About this source
French asks what about the video is supposed to be appealing and answers that it is the whiteness.
- Author
- David French
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Critics Charge ICE With Bringing Back 'Jim Crow' In A New Ad Touting America 'The Way It Was'
Relevant passage: Article, November 13, 2026 (Yahoo News copy of the Mediaite story)
About this source
Mediaite describes the scenes and on-screen text of ICE's recruitment video and quotes the X posts of David French, Maria Cardona, Aaron Reichlin-Melnick and Alyssa Farah Griffin.
- Author
- Jennifer Bowers Bahney
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- ICE posts a recruitment video promising "the way it can be again"; critics call it racist, and Sierra Ferrell says the agency used her song without permission
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/ice-the-way-it-was-recruitment-video-sierra-ferrell
The Dispute Index. "ICE posts a recruitment video promising "the way it can be again"; critics call it racist, and Sierra Ferrell says the agency used her song without permission". First published: 2026-11-17. Last updated: 2026-11-17. https://disputeindex.com/cases/ice-the-way-it-was-recruitment-video-sierra-ferrell