EcoShield customers sue, alleging pest control contracts disguised cancellation fees as discounts
EcoShield Pest Solutions customers allege in federal class actions that the door-to-door pest control company disguised cancellation fees as discounts and hid contract terms. The companies have asked courts to dismiss the suits. Michigan's attorney general also challenged its contracts.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
Customers of EcoShield Pest Solutions, a pest control business that sells recurring service plans door to door, have filed proposed class actions in federal courts in Colorado, Arizona and Georgia. They allege that EcoShield's contracts present a cancellation fee as a discount and that its salespeople do not disclose cancellation terms, contract length or automatic renewal. The Colorado suit was voluntarily dismissed in June 2025. The EcoShield companies have asked the Arizona and Georgia courts to dismiss the claims, and the Georgia case was paused for mediation in December 2025. In 2024, Michigan's attorney general said EcoShield's Detroit contracts tried to waive customers' cancellation rights; the company agreed to stop using them without admitting wrongdoing.
Read the full background
EcoShield Pest Solutions sells recurring pest control plans, often through salespeople who go door to door. Its local offices are run as separate companies, such as EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, LLC. The website of The Shield Companies (opens in a new tab) says its Shield Management arm supports the local EcoShield service offices and Shield Marketing oversees direct marketing for the branches.
In April 2024, Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel's office told EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC to cease and desist (opens in a new tab) and amend its contracts. The office said the contracts allegedly tried to waive customers' three-day right to cancel a door-to-door sale and their right to refunds, and lacked the required notice of cancellation form. In a June 2024 Assurance of Voluntary Compliance (opens in a new tab), the company said it had stopped using its 2023 contracts and agreed to refund Michigan customers who showed they were denied cancellation. It also said it offered the agreement to avoid the cost of litigation and that the agreement is not an admission of wrongdoing.
The first class action was filed (opens in a new tab) on April 3, 2025 in federal court in Colorado by Patrick Shaffer. His complaint says his service agreement applied a $150 "Annual Commitment Discount" to his first visit, then EcoShield charged him $150 to cancel after he had paid for a full year of service, although the agreement lists no cancellation fee. It also says the agreement renews automatically after its initial term. Shaffer voluntarily dismissed (opens in a new tab) the suit on June 23, 2025, and the court dismissed the case without prejudice the next day.
On June 19, 2025, Nicholas Lamonica and Michael Clemente of Illinois sued (opens in a new tab) The Shield Companies, two affiliated Shield companies, EcoShield Pest Solutions Chicago and The Shield Companies' members, Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren, in federal court in Arizona, seeking to represent customers nationwide. They allege that EcoShield salespeople describe a standard contract discount as a limited-time offer, do not orally tell customers of their three-day right to cancel, and later demand the discount back as a cancellation fee. Clemente left the case in August, and an October 2025 amended complaint (opens in a new tab) added customers from New Jersey and Michigan and EcoShield's Detroit and New Jersey companies. The companies moved to dismiss in October 2025 and again on June 23, 2026, after another amended complaint. The docket (opens in a new tab) lists an order on that motion dated November 10, 2026. We could not review the court's orders in the Arizona case, so we do not know how it ruled.
Stephen Nelson of Georgia filed a similar suit (opens in a new tab) in federal court in Atlanta on July 18, 2025, through the law firm that brought the Colorado case. He says his invoice called the $250 charge he paid to cancel an "Annual Commitment Discount Payback", although his contract mentions no such discount. EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta and the other defendants moved to dismiss on October 14, 2025. On December 23, 2025, the court granted the parties' joint request (opens in a new tab) to pause the case for mediation and held the motions under advisement. We could not find a public record of later developments in the Georgia case as of November 17, 2026.
The East Hampton Star (opens in a new tab) reported in September 2025 that East Hampton residents had complained to police about EcoShield salespeople going door to door that summer. We did not find a public statement from EcoShield or The Shield Companies about the lawsuits as of November 17, 2026, and we could not review the companies' motions to dismiss. The complaints state the customers' allegations, which have not been proven.
Timeline
12 timeline entries on this page. Dates: April 22, 2024 to July 23, 2026
April 2024
Michigan attorney general tells EcoShield's Detroit company to change its contracts
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel's office sent EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit a notice of intended action, announced on April 24, telling it to cease and desist from what the office called unlawful business practices and to amend contracts that allegedly tried to waive customers' cancellation and refund rights.
June 2024
EcoShield's Detroit company signs compliance agreement with Michigan
The Michigan attorney general's office filed an Assurance of Voluntary Compliance with EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit in Ingham County Circuit Court. The company agreed to keep using revised contracts and to refund customers who showed they were denied cancellation, and the agreement states that it is not an admission of wrongdoing.
April 2025
Colorado customer files proposed class action over EcoShield cancellation fee
Incident
Patrick Shaffer sued EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, The Shield Companies, The Shield Co Management, Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren in federal court in Colorado. He alleges that a $150 "Annual Commitment Discount" in his service agreement worked as a cancellation fee the agreement never disclosed.
June 2025
Illinois customers file nationwide class action against The Shield Companies in Arizona
Incident
Nicholas Lamonica and Michael Clemente sued The Shield Companies, The Shield Co Management, The Shield Co Marketing, EcoShield Pest Solutions Chicago, Cardon and Nygren in federal court in Arizona. They allege that EcoShield salespeople use high-pressure door-to-door tactics and present cancellation fees as discounts.
Shaffer voluntarily dismisses Colorado suit
Shaffer filed a notice of voluntary dismissal, and on June 24 Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney dismissed the case without prejudice. The defendants had not yet answered the complaint.
July 2025
Georgia customer files proposed class action against EcoShield's Atlanta company
Incident
Stephen Nelson sued EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, The Shield Companies, The Shield Co Management, Cardon and Nygren in federal court in Atlanta. He alleges that a $250 "Initial Discount" in his service agreement was charged back to him as an undisclosed cancellation fee.
October 2025
Arizona suit amended to add New Jersey and Michigan customers
The plaintiffs in the Arizona case filed a second amended complaint that adds customers from New Jersey and Michigan, adds EcoShield's Detroit and New Jersey companies as defendants and brings claims under those states' consumer protection laws. Michael Clemente had dismissed his own claims in August.
EcoShield companies ask Georgia court to dismiss Nelson's suit
EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, The Shield Co Management and The Shield Companies filed a motion to dismiss Nelson's complaint for failure to state a claim. Cardon and Nygren filed a separate motion to dismiss.
EcoShield companies move to dismiss Arizona suit
The Shield companies, the EcoShield companies in Chicago, Detroit and New Jersey, Cardon and Nygren filed a motion to dismiss the second amended complaint for failure to state a claim. The plaintiffs filed their opposition on November 13, 2025.
December 2025
Georgia court pauses Nelson case for mediation
Judge Sarah E. Geraghty granted the parties' joint motion to stay the case pending mediation and said the court would hold the defendants' motions to dismiss under advisement during the stay.
June 2026
New motion to dismiss filed in Arizona case after another amended complaint
A new motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim was filed on June 23, 2026, two weeks after the plaintiffs filed another amended complaint with the court's permission. The docket lists an order on the motion dated November 10, 2026. We could not review the order.
July 2026
EcoShield's Milwaukee-area company answers a BBB letter about a pattern of complaints
A Better Business Bureau alert says EcoShield Pest Solutions, which serves Milwaukee County, was sent a letter in October 2024 about a pattern of complaints alleging aggressive and non-transparent sales practices, undisclosed pricing and undisclosed fees to cancel. According to the BBB, the company responded on July 23, 2026, saying it had added a text verification after enrollment that invites customers to ask questions or raise concerns. The BBB says the company also reported updating its written service agreement's language on pricing, contract duration, automatic renewal and cancellation fees.
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
EcoShield Pest SolutionsPest control company, through EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC in an agreement its lawyers signed with the Michigan attorney general "Respondent is offering this Assurance to avoid the time and expense of litigating COD's concerns. This Assurance, and Petitioner's acceptance of it, does not constitute an admission of wrongdoing by Respondent."
Mixed or conditionalCase context: EcoShield customers sue, alleging pest control contracts disguised cancellation fees as discounts
Full statement and sources
In a June 2024 agreement with Michigan's attorney general, EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit said it had stopped using its 2023 contracts and would refund customers who were denied cancellation, while saying it entered the agreement to avoid the cost of litigation and admits no wrongdoing.
Before the statement
The agreement says the attorney general's office alleged that the company's 2023 Michigan contracts tried to make consumers waive their three-day cancellation and refund rights and lacked the required notice of cancellation, and that the company answered with a revised 2024 contract.
After the statement
It goes on to say that the company has stopped using the 2023 contracts, will keep using the revised language and comply with Michigan law, and will refund customers who contact the office by December 31, 2024 with proof that they were denied cancellation or a refund.
Dana Nessel, Attorney General v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC: Assurance of Voluntary ComplianceCase No. 24-230-CP (Ingham County Circuit Court), paragraphs 2.1-6.5 and signature pageWhy this label?
The case concerns allegations that EcoShield's door-to-door subscription contracts did not properly disclose cancellation rights and terms. In its Michigan agreement, EcoShield's Detroit company stopped using the challenged contracts and agreed to refunds, but said it settled to avoid litigation costs and admitted no wrongdoing, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
EcoShield Pest SolutionsPest control company, through Sara Blanchfield, its director of customer care, in a statement to Denver7 "We have invested significant time, resources and technology into making sure that we have safeguards in place to ensure that our customers review, know and agree to the terms of their service with our family during the sign up process We conduct ourselves with the intent to set the standard of excellence in our industry when it comes to thoroughness, accuracy and integrity at the point of sale."
Stood by itCase context: EcoShield customers sue, alleging pest control contracts disguised cancellation fees as discounts
Full statement and sources
Answering Denver residents who said they were misled about what they would pay, EcoShield's director of customer care, Sara Blanchfield, told Denver7 that the company has invested in safeguards so customers review, know and agree to their terms when they sign up.
Before the statement
Denver7 reported that one Denver resident said he agreed with an EcoShield salesperson to pay $179 for a year of service and learned a few days later that he had been enrolled in quarterly payments. A neighbor said the salesperson had repeatedly assured her there would be no further charges.
After the statement
Blanchfield also told Denver7 she hoped to reach the two residents so they could be taken care of as an act of good faith. One of them said he was eventually able to cancel without paying the high cancellation fee he had first been threatened with.
Denver residents accuse pest control company of 'shady' business after being enrolled in recurring paymentsParagraphs on the statement EcoShield's customer care department sent to Denver7, and the closing paragraphsWhy this label?
Blanchfield answers the residents' complaints by saying EcoShield's sign-up process has safeguards so customers review, know and agree to their terms, and that the company aims for integrity at the point of sale, so we labeled it Stood by it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
No responses match these filters.
Clear response filtersSources
(17)
Original text
Lamonica v. The Shield Companies, LLC: class action complaint
Relevant passage: No. 2:25-cv-02151 (D. Ariz.), Document 1, paragraphs 1-2 and 12-52
About this source
Complaint Nicholas Lamonica and Michael Clemente, two Illinois customers, filed on June 19, 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona against The Shield Companies, LLC, The Shield Co Management, LLC, The Shield Co Marketing, LLC, EcoShield Pest Solutions Chicago, LLC, Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren. It states the plaintiffs' allegations about EcoShield's door-to-door sales and contracts; it does not establish the facts. Filed copy from the federal court docket.
- Author
- Perez Law Group, Gianaris Trial Lawyers and Simmons Hanly Conroy, counsel for Nicholas Lamonica and Michael Clemente
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
EcoShield Pest Solutions, New Berlin, Wisconsin: BBB business profile, information and alerts
Relevant passage: Alert details: Pattern of Complaints
About this source
Better Business Bureau profile page for EcoShield Pest Solutions in New Berlin, Wisconsin, which BBB Serving Wisconsin lists under the name EcoShield Pest Solutions Milwaukee, LLC. Its pattern-of-complaints alert says when the BBB wrote to the company and summarizes the response the company sent on July 23, 2026. The page gives no publication date.
- Accessed
Official statement
EcoShield Lawsuit | Door-to-Door Pest Control Deception [2026 Investigation]
Relevant passage: Opening section and the overview of the class action lawsuit
About this source
Web page in which Gianaris Trial Lawyers describes the class action it filed against EcoShield with co-counsel and invites EcoShield customers to contact the firm. The firm first published it in July 2025 and has updated it since. The page says the suit was filed in the Superior Court for Maricopa County; the complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Denver residents accuse pest control company of 'shady' business after being enrolled in recurring payments
Relevant passage: Paragraphs on the statement EcoShield's customer care department sent to Denver7, and the closing paragraphs
About this source
Denver7 report on two Denver residents who said an EcoShield salesperson misled them about what they would pay. It quotes the statement the station received from Sara Blanchfield, EcoShield's director of customer care.
- Author
- Rob Harris
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
EcoShield Sales Tactics Irk Many
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
The East Hampton Star report on residents' complaints to police about EcoShield door-to-door salespeople in East Hampton during the summer of 2025. It describes the affiliated Shield companies and summarizes the class action filed in federal court in Arizona in June 2025.
- Author
- Bettina Neel
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Dana Nessel, Attorney General v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC: Assurance of Voluntary Compliance
Relevant passage: Case No. 24-230-CP (Ingham County Circuit Court), paragraphs 2.1-6.5 and signature page
About this source
Assurance of Voluntary Compliance and Discontinuance signed by an assistant attorney general on June 20, 2024 and by EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit's lawyers on June 19, 2024, with the office's filing letter to the court. It sets out the office's allegations about the company's 2023 Michigan contracts, the company's commitments and its statement that the agreement is not an admission of wrongdoing.
- Author
- Michigan Department of Attorney General and Lewis Roca Rothgerber Christie LLP, counsel for EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
AG Nessel Reaches Compliance Agreement with EcoShield Pest Solutions for Alleged Consumer Protection Violations
Relevant passage: Full release
About this source
Press release from the Michigan attorney general's office announcing the Assurance of Voluntary Compliance and Discontinuance filed in Ingham County Circuit Court with EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC. It summarizes the terms, including revised contracts and refunds for customers who were denied cancellation.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
AG Nessel Issues Cease and Desist Order to Pest Control Business for Alleged Consumer Protection Violations
Relevant passage: Full release
About this source
Press release from Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel's office announcing that EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC was told to cease and desist and amend its contracts under the Michigan Home Solicitation Sales Act and Consumer Protection Act. It describes the office's allegations about the contracts and quotes Nessel.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Nelson v. Ecoshield Pest Solutions Atlanta, LLC et al: docket report
Relevant passage: Filings 24-34, October 14 to December 23, 2025
About this source
Docket report for the Georgia case as published by Justia from the court's records, last updated December 23, 2025. Filing 34 is Judge Sarah E. Geraghty's order granting the parties' joint motion to stay the case pending mediation and holding the motions to dismiss under advisement during the stay.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Nelson v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, LLC, No. 1:25-cv-03988 (N.D. Ga.): docket
Relevant passage: Docket entries 1-25, July 18 to October 14, 2025
About this source
Court docket as mirrored by CourtListener (RECAP), with the full docket text through October 14, 2025. Entries 24 and 25 are the two motions to dismiss for failure to state a claim, one filed by EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, The Shield Co Management and The Shield Companies, the other by Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Nelson v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, LLC: class action complaint
Relevant passage: No. 1:25-cv-03988 (N.D. Ga.), Document 1, paragraphs 1-11 and 25-44
About this source
Complaint Stephen Nelson filed on July 18, 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia against EcoShield Pest Solutions Atlanta, LLC, The Shield Companies, LLC, The Shield Co Management, LLC, Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren, with his service agreement attached. It states Nelson's allegations; it does not establish the facts. Filed copy from the federal court docket.
- Author
- Wittels McInturff Palikovic and Weiner & Sand LLC, counsel for Stephen Nelson
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Lamonica et al v. Shield Companies LLC et al: docket report
Relevant passage: Filings 1-33, June 19 to December 11, 2025
About this source
Docket report for the Arizona case as published by Justia from the court's records, last updated December 11, 2025. It gives the full docket text for each filing, including Michael Clemente's August 25, 2025 notice dismissing his own claims and the defendants' October 16, 2025 motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Lamonica v. Shield Companies LLC, No. 2:25-cv-02151 (D. Ariz.): docket
Relevant passage: Docket entries 1-59, June 20, 2025 to November 10, 2026
About this source
Court docket as mirrored by CourtListener (RECAP). It lists each filing by date with a short description, including the motions to dismiss filed October 16, 2025 and June 23, 2026, the amended complaints of October 14, 2025 and June 9, 2026, and an order on the motion to dismiss entered November 10, 2026. The mirror holds the text of the complaint and second amended complaint but not of the motions or orders.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Lamonica v. The Shield Companies, LLC: second amended class action complaint
Relevant passage: No. 2:25-cv-02151 (D. Ariz.), Document 24, paragraphs 1-14
About this source
Second amended complaint filed on October 14, 2025 by Nicholas Lamonica of Illinois, Valerio Bruscianelli of New Jersey and Joel and Rebekah Walma of Michigan. It adds EcoShield Pest Solutions Detroit, LLC and EcoShield Pest Solutions New Jersey, LLC as defendants and claims under the New Jersey and Michigan consumer protection laws. It states the plaintiffs' allegations; it does not establish the facts. Filed copy from the federal court docket.
- Author
- Perez Law Group and co-counsel, counsel for the plaintiffs
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Shaffer v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, LLC et al: docket report
Relevant passage: Filings 12-15, June 9 to June 24, 2025
About this source
Docket report for the Colorado case as published by Justia from the court's records, last updated June 24, 2025. Filing 14 is Shaffer's June 23 notice of voluntary dismissal, and filing 15 is the June 24 minute order by Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney dismissing the case without prejudice.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Shaffer v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, LLC, No. 1:25-cv-01057 (D. Colo.): docket
Relevant passage: Docket entries of April 3 to June 24, 2025
About this source
Court docket as mirrored by CourtListener (RECAP). It lists the April 3, 2025 complaint, the assignment of the case, a June 9 motion for more time to respond and a June 24 minute order closing the case.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Shaffer v. EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, LLC: class action complaint
Relevant passage: No. 1:25-cv-01057 (D. Colo.), Document 1, paragraphs 1-11 and 34-61
About this source
Complaint Patrick Shaffer filed on April 3, 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado against EcoShield Pest Solutions Denver, LLC, The Shield Companies, LLC, The Shield Co Management, LLC, Robert Douglas Cardon and Gregory Nygren, seeking to represent a nationwide class of EcoShield customers. It states Shaffer's allegations; it does not establish the facts. Filed copy from the federal court docket.
- Author
- Wittels McInturff Palikovic, counsel for Patrick Shaffer
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- EcoShield customers sue, alleging pest control contracts disguised cancellation fees as discounts
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/ecoshield-lawsuits-cancellation-fees
The Dispute Index. "EcoShield customers sue, alleging pest control contracts disguised cancellation fees as discounts". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/ecoshield-lawsuits-cancellation-fees