The Dispute Index

Case history

Recent changes

Read additions and corrections to published cases, newest first.

  1. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Did border policy cause Maine’s overdose deaths to fall?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The researcher disputes evidence linking the administration's cited enforcement steps to falling overdose deaths. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Drug Policy and Overdose Response.
    After
    Topic associations: Public Health; Immigration Policy; Drug Policy.

  2. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Did border policy cause Maine’s overdose deaths to fall?

    Taxonomy-only correction. Alongside the border/overdose causal dispute, the summary substantively identifies treatment access as an alternative contributor. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Drug Policy and Overdose Response.
    After
    Topic associations: Public Health; Immigration Policy; Drug Policy; Health Care.

  3. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Did border policy cause Maine’s overdose deaths to fall?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The researcher directly disputes the claim that the border has stopped fentanyl entry and links it to continuing overdose deaths. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Drug Policy and Overdose Response.
    After
    Topic associations: Public Health; Immigration Policy; Drug Policy.

  4. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Did border policy cause Maine’s overdose deaths to fall?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The researcher contests a single border-closing explanation for the fentanyl overdose decline and invokes multiple population-health contributors. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Drug Policy and Overdose Response.
    After
    Topic associations: Public Health; Immigration Policy; Drug Policy.

  5. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Hasan Piker’s “Hamas over Israel” comparison

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the Israel/Hamas moral comparison, civilian harm or tactics, and Palestinian resistance or interests. An antisemitism topic is not automatically inferred. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence; Antisemitism.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; Political Violence; Palestine.

  6. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the October 7 warning story together with alleged media misconduct, reporting pressure, libel, or the outlet's defense. Israeli election references are not U.S. 2026 Midterm Elections. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks; Media.

  7. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the October 7 warning story together with alleged media misconduct, reporting pressure, libel, or the outlet's defense. Israeli election references are not U.S. 2026 Midterm Elections. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks; Media.

  8. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Hasan Piker’s “Hamas over Israel” comparison

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the Israel/Hamas moral comparison, civilian harm or tactics, and Palestinian resistance or interests. An antisemitism topic is not automatically inferred. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence; Antisemitism.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; Political Violence; Palestine.

  9. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Hasan Piker’s “Hamas over Israel” comparison

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Combines explicit condemnation of Hamas and rejection of Netanyahu's policies with a substantive turn to electoral priorities; it does not independently classify Piker's comment as antisemitic. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence; Antisemitism.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; Political Violence; 2026 Midterm Elections.

  10. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  11. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  12. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Hasan Piker’s “Hamas over Israel” comparison

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the Israel/Hamas moral comparison, civilian harm or tactics, and Palestinian resistance or interests. An antisemitism topic is not automatically inferred. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence; Antisemitism.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; Political Violence; Palestine.

  13. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  14. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the October 7 warning story together with alleged media misconduct, reporting pressure, libel, or the outlet's defense. Israeli election references are not U.S. 2026 Midterm Elections. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks; Media.

  15. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  16. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  17. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Was Netanyahu warned by the UAE about a major Hamas operation before October 7?

    Topic taxonomy maintenance only. Addresses the specific warning, evidence, official response, or responsibility for October 7; no broad Political Violence tag is needed for a record/credibility dispute alone. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: October 7 Intelligence and Government Accountability; Israel and Zionism; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: Israel; October 7 Attacks.

  18. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. Sparacio explicitly contests the religious-discrimination explanation while opposing memorial attendance on policy and association grounds. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks; Islamophobia.

  19. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. Hanif explicitly argues that exclusion from the September 11 memorial treats Mamdani differently because he is Muslim. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks; Islamophobia.

  20. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The objection is specifically to speaking at the commemoration, not necessarily attendance or religious identity. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks.

  21. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The statement predicts spiteful attendance and discusses disengagement at the memorial. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks.

  22. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The direct request is to stay away from the Ground Zero commemoration. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks.

  23. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The criticism concerns attendance as disrespect toward grieving families. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks.

  24. Corrected

    Reporting corrected

    In Should Zohran Mamdani attend New York City’s 9/11 memorial?

    Taxonomy-only correction. The lightning-rod objection concerns distraction from September 11 victims and families, not a new religious or violence claim. The quotation, attribution, stance classification, sources, and dates are unchanged.

    Before
    Topic associations: Anti-Muslim Bigotry and Islamophobia; Political Rhetoric and Violence.
    After
    Topic associations: September 11 Attacks.
Older changes